Tuesday, November 1, 2011

An Examination of Kindness

This week we were asked to read two chapters that proved to be both interesting and meaningful in their content. The readings consisted of the first and last chapter of On Kindness by Adam Phillips and Barabara Taylor. As the title suggests, the chapters provided an in-depth examination of kindness, particularly how kindness is relevant to everyday life.

In the first chapter, Phillips and Taylor begin their argument that kindness is a truly pleasurable activity (4). Some evidence they provide includes a quote by Theodor Adorno, who declared “No less indiscriminate and general than the alienation between people is the desire to breach it” (6). The authors expound upon this idea of alienation versus communal kindness, defining kindness as “the ability to bear the vulnerability of others, and therefore of oneself” (8). It is suggested that kindness is equated with weakness in modern times as a result of this vulnerability (8). This is taken a step further when Phillips and Taylor infer that vulnerability is an essential element of the individual that helps tie humanity together (11-12).

Phillips’ and Taylor’s assessment of kindness is continued throughout the final chapter of their book. The authors open with a quote to introduce their next point: despite the modern desire for independence, being sympathetic and needing others is part of what it means to be human (95-96). Shortly into the chapter, a 1970 study by Richard Titmuss is used as further support that humans are inherently kind. The study involved a poll of British blood donors, where 98.2 percent of the donors “said they did it to assist someone whom they would never meet” (100). Phillips and Taylor staunchly maintain this position of inherent kindness for the duration of the chapter, contending opposition such that kindness is an impossible goal for the masses or that people are kind to make them feel better about themselves (110-111).

To a large degree, I feel the claims Phillips and Taylor make are valid. There are countless examples of people deriving great enjoyment from helping others and ultimately feeling that their life is more fulfilling. For me, it is essentially this aspect that causes me to enjoy and value service projects like the volunteer work I am doing for Coleman Elementary school. It is also the reason I would like to have a career of providing people with a meaningful service by becoming a physician.

- Christopher Galbick

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.