Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Understanding Perceptions

The fourth chapter of Appiah's "Cosmopolitanism" entitles Moral Disagreement introduces the concept of "thin" and "thick" values.  The morality of the world consists of a mixture of both types of values; "Once you understand the system, you'll be likely to agree: and it won't be because you've given up any of your basic moral commitments.  There are thin, universal values here...but their expression is highly particular, thickly enmeshed with local customs and expectations and the facts of social arrangements" (49).  In every society, there are the same thin universal values, such as pride and respect for elders, however these values coexist with the thick values of each specific society.  Because all individuals come from different societies, each with distinct traditions, beliefs, and values, that disagreements are created.  According to Appiah, "...the most fundamental level of disagreement occurs when one party to a discussion invokes a concept that the other simply doesn't have.  This is the kind of disagreement where the struggle is not to agree but just to understand" (47).  It is difficult for us to understand the views of others, even if we share similar thin values, because our thick values are unique to each individual.  This idea can especially be related back to my experience with service learning at MCCS.  While the students and I can see eye to eye on certain subjects, we fail to view other matters, such as prioritizing school work, in the same way.  This is due to the different thick values we accept.  While I grew up in a setting where education and respect were top priorities, many of the students were raised in a completely different setting.
The main concept which stood out to me the most in the fifth chapter, The Primacy of Practice, was that individuals can value the same thing, but because of different reasons.  Appiah uses the example, "If my interest is in discouraging theft, I needn't worry that one person might refrain from theft because she believes in the Golden Rule; another because of her conception of personal integrity; a third because she thinks God frowns on it" (69).  The thing that matters is that all three people are refraining from committing and theft; and as a result their justifications are not as significant.  Without this ideal, society would not be able to function as it is today; "indeed, our political coexistence, as subjects or citizens, depends on being able to agree about practices while disagreeing about their justification" (70).  
The chapter Imaginary Strangers introduces an especially powerful concept, which is often overlooked during times of distress and disagreement.  Cross cultural conversations do not require universals in order to be successful.  Appiah writes "...the points of entry to cross cultural conversations are things that are shared by those who are in the conversation.  They do not need to be universal; all they need to be is what these particular people have in common.  Once we have found enough we share, there is the further possibility that we will be able to enjoy discovering things we do not yet share" (97).  This concept can also be related to my experience at MCCS.  I do not relate to all the students because of specific universals which are always true; i relate to them individually, starting from the things we have in common.  From there a relationship is formed, and then other issues which we may not agree upon can be discussed without fear of reproach.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.