Monday, November 1, 2010

The Bigger Picture

According to Guignon, "we all draw our concrete ways of understanding and evaluating ourselves from the pool of possible interpretations made accessible in the social context in which we find ourselves" (127). As "socially constituted" (126) collective individuals, our definitions of self are as much (or even more) determined by our positions and experiences in society as they are by self-reflection and internal evaluation. Rather than seeing this inevitable social integration and impact as a bane, though, Guignon examines the boons of such a way of living, and the greater moral implications leading interconnected lives forces us to face.

Guignon's discussion on the "social embodiment" (163) aspect of authenticity speaks most prevalently and relevantly to me, to see "life [as] as open-ended and inconclusive project" (129) due to the influences and inclusion of an ever-changing world and ever-morphing society; as Freire put it in his Pedagogy of Freedom, the "unfinishedness" of humanity. Guignon argues that given this truth, that we can never truly "become" ourselves unless we acknowledge that we never actually had to, nor never really can become ourselves, we must thereby strive to "envisage some range of goals and ideals and do our best to bring them to realization, leaving the rest of the contingencies of the real world" (129).

Guignon also notes that as humans we are "inescapably embedded in a wider context of meaning, a tradition, which itself has the shape of an unfolding narrative" (135). We are the products, and the producers, of our given realities. We are the victims of our circumstances, and also the creators of the lives we choose to lead. Either way, we are always in some way, constantly connected to the greater. Losing sight of our interconnectedness not just within ourselves, but also to the world as a far larger whole, we run the "risk of slipping into a life so prone to self-absorption and compulsive self-surveillance that one becomes isolated from all those who share this preoccupation" (147). In focusing solely on ourselves, we sacrifice that vital human experience of being and becoming a force within the larger and more collective force.

"... The ability to be a reflective individual who discerns what is genuinely worth pursuing within the social context in which he or she is situated," influenced but not completely swayed by society, is to Guignon a part of the ideal of authenticity. I agree largely with this philosophy. I don't believe that anyone can truly and wholely escape the grasp or influence of "society." I don't think that isolation guarantees a deeper searching and discovering of self, nor do I believe that society always knows what is right.

In struggling to find balance between autonomy and conformity within myself, I see authenticity as the power and courage to develop one's own internal self despite the influences that our modern society forces upon us. To acknowledge the existence of societal norms, and to allow them infiltrate our worldviews, but also to sort through what we are told and to stay true to our own, deeply personal opinions.

In my work at Canal Alliance, I am seeing Guignon's arguments for authenticity as both a personal and social virtue in my approach to my service learning. I feel as though I am developing myself as an individual through the volunteer work I am doing to (hopefully) benefit others. But beyond selfish motivations to improve myself, I am genuinely loving the experience of teaching others some of the things I have come to take for granted, which has consequently led to me realize how fortunate I am to be where I am and to have had the education I have, and to appreciate that which I am doing for others that someone at one point has had to do for me.

"This sort of releasement means no longer putting ourselves at the center of the picture, no longer letting our egos get in the way in every situation. It points to a way of getting into the swim of what is going on around us without asking where we stand in it all" (165).


Phillipa Armes

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.