Since we all like to think of ourselves, and more broadly, our communities and various related units as unique, do we have a fear of homogeneity? I think that it's safe to say that yes, yes we do. The fact that Appiah sees this phenomenon in the flip side was quite interesting to me, and he worded it in a way that I never really thought of before. Globalization is a threat to cultural homogeneity. Our increasingly more accessible and user-friendly global network is playing a part in not just bringing us together as an international and multiracial and diverse community, it is also playing a part in dividing and separating already somewhat homogenized groups, such as tribal communities, tight-knit families, culturally accepted norms, etc.
But within this division, there is infinite space for beauty and growth. Within these "threatened" communities, "whatever loss of difference there has been, they are constantly inventing new forms of difference" (103). Things are constantly changing. We can "sympathize" with cultures that are perhaps losing their pre-globalization-boom roots, "but we cannot force their children to stay in the name of protecting their authentic culture; and we cannot afford to subsidize indefinitely thousands of distinct islands of homogeneity that no longer make economic sense" (104).
So can we deem today's generation, my generation, as being "inauthentic," simply because the values and practices of communities around the world today may not exactly mirror those of their respective ancestors so many years ago? If we take Appiah's theory (and the general consensus) that things are in constant motion and change, then we cannot blame this generation's differences from previous ones. We adapt. We shift. And we practice and preserve as our present sees fit.
With this global community now taking precedence above our more local communities, the issues of morality and loyalties come into question, and Appiah poses the question to us: What are we doing to actually help the world today? Are there universals binding us together morally? I particularly enjoyed Appiah's discussions around the drowning child and giving to the needy. When are our actions not enough? Where do we draw the line between selfishness and selflessness? "... Cosmopolitan moral judgment requires us to feel about everyone in the world what we feel about our literal neighbors (a strength of feeling that is perhaps exaggerated by the suggestion that for them, at least, we would risk our lives)" (157-8).
"So how much do we really owe to strangers?" (158). I personally would certainly show any stranger the respect, kindness, and love I would like to receive in return (there's that twisted Golden Rule again...), and then some. But to universalize my own ideals would be un-cosmopolitan of me. So to address a few of Appiah's questions regarding how I would react in a certain situation... I honestly don't feel compelled to donate all of my money following a natural disaster. I would rather occasionally dish out what I could afford to give (as a starving artist and student) unconditionally. I would rather give frequently to charities that I stand behind and believe in (I give generously to the SPCA when I can). I would rather save the drowning child than stand there and do nothing (I should thank my overbearing guilty conscious for that one too...) - who wouldn't?
In my Service-Learning, I don't necessarily see myself as doing some "kindness to strangers" as much as I am doing something good for myself and because my students have shown a desire and interest in learning what they are here to learn. It is one thing to provide a service to a willing student, and another to talk to a brick wall. In the classroom, as we learned from Freire's Pedagogy of Freedom, it is all about give, give, give, and take. I am not saving anyone, and I am not providing a charitable service (be it voluntary or not). I am doing something for someone because I believe in the cause, and because someone has a passion and desire to better themselves on their own accord. Natural disaster not required.
Phillipa Armes
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.