Saturday, November 13, 2010

The Inevitable in Mirrors: Shards and Wholes

"Only in the past couple of centuries, as every human community has gradually been drawn into a single web of trade and a global network of information, have we come to a point where each of us can realistically imagine contacting any other of our six billion conspecifics and sending that person something worth having" (xii).

The introduction of Appiah's Cosmopolitanism brings to light the important point that we today live in both an insufferably and beautifully interconnected world. Nothing can be seen as entirely independent of something else, and no individual can hope to thrive without in some way looking to someone or something else for services, advice, or goods. In the twenty-first century, human existence, quite frankly, depends upon this "web" of communication and marketplace. With this truth comes a degree of responsibility and accountability, as Appiah puts it, this relatively new global social structure brings with it the likelihood that we are to either consciously or unintentionally "send... things that will cause harm" (xii).

As we all know though, we tend to view the advancement of technology as an avenue to also "learn about life anywhere" (xiii), leading to the discussion of "cosmopolitanism." Defined as "'citizen of the cosmos'" (xiv), Appiah believes that the origins of the concept of cosmopolitanism stem from the ideal that there is no smaller entity than the whole, the complete "mirror" (8). As humans, though we fail to understand this almost extremist viewpoint in thinking that our "little shard[s] of mirror" (8), or our realities within our smaller communities, are a true representation of the whole, as opposed to a very small and vastly subjective portion of the bigger picture.

Appiah takes this metaphor further to describe morality: "perhaps... there is no singular truth. In that case, there's no one shattered mirror; there are lots of mirrors, lost of moral truths, and we can at best agree to differ" (11). Though we are pawns and facets in this interconnected global community, we are also pawns and facets within our smaller, closer-to-home communities. And within those smaller networks, we find our deepest roots, values, morals, and traditions. So it must come down to a matter of keeping in tune with these deeply rooted home values we grow up with, but also "picking and choosing among options [we] find in [our] search[es] [through life]" (5). We create our own moral backbones based on our pasts, our experiences, and our global connections. "There are some values that are, and should be, universal, just as there are lots of values that are, and must be, local" (xxi). Yin and yang. Whole and shard.

In my Service Learning, I am coming to appreciate these wholes and shards within my students. I am trying to see the world through their eyes. They have come from the shards that they thought were the whole, until they left those small communities and attained access to portals to introduce them to the real whole. As Appiah puts it, "the world is getting more crowded... Depending on the circumstances, conversations across boundaries can be delightful, or just vexing: what they mainly are, though, is inevitable" (xxi). I am hoping to prepare these newly integrated shards to the whole to be prepared for the inevitable.


Phillipa Armes

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.