As the Asante say according to Appiah, "the stranger never grows to perfection" (93). But what if one's ideal of perfection is to maintain cordial niceties without becoming intwined in another's life? I believe there can be a "perfect stranger." In my neighborhood at home in NC, there is this strange and foreign concept to me in which everyone feels the need to know and encroach on each others' business. There is no privacy, it seems, and no anonymity. There are faces to every name, and little to be imagined. "If someone hates you, he won't ask you for things" (92). A little more extreme than being simply "strangers," but you get the idea. Is it really so wrong to not fully know somebody? Is it that detestable to have relationships on different levels? In contemporary American society (or at least in the communities I have recently been exposed to), it seems as though the more you know about the other, the "closer" you are. But this lack of space in proximity, for me, more often breeds contempt.
By Appiah's reasoning, "once someone has translated the language you don't know, or explained some little unfamiliar symbol or custom, you'll have no more (and, of course, no less) trouble understanding why they do what they do than you do making sense of your neighbors back home" (94). So if this holds true, why do we consistently hit the roadblock of misunderstanding and fear of the unknown if we could just boil it down to the essential fact that we are intrinsically human, and therefore in some ways, all the same? There are "statistical norm[s] in every society" (95).
As a minority (and a strange hybrid of one) in a mostly white American culture, I feel most comfortable and un-singled-out in a blended society. I take comfort in my anonymity... so cities like San Francisco and New York and London start to look appealing. I can blend. In knowing that we are each human and leading our own, equally important existences in the human highways of the world, I think we should be able to find "warmth and power [in this] shared identity" (98). To me, humanity IS an identity... And one that we all share.
As a cosmopolitan, I thrive off of learning the unknown and experiencing the new, which I am so happy to be immersed in in my Service-Learning at Canal Alliance. I am constantly learning from these "strangers" that I teach, probably more so than they are learning from me. We don't know everything about each other, but that does not make our experiences in the classroom together any less vital or any less viable. We are aspects of, and engaged within, each others' lives. We are indisputable players in each others' games, and our ability to communicate through language, social, and relationship divides and differences is truly beautiful.
"... when a stranger is no longer imaginary, but real and present, sharing a human social life, you may like or dislike him, you may agree or disagree; but, if it is what you both want, you can make sense of each other in the end" (99). We are making sense.
Phillipa Armes
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.