Individuals in modern times are grappling with finally obtaining the long fought for and flourishing independence in their relationship with society. No longer are our actions pre-judged based off of our ranking. I was not born a baker, nor would society ever judge me only in that role were it to be my profession. I am free to determine and pursue my own interests to the best of my abilities. Questions start arising quickly though, including how to judge our wants, pursue our wants, and what affect do ethics have on the answers to these questions. The independence of thought and action can force us to questions what is good and bad. Further, with the secularization seen in modern philosophy, we must decide what motivating and determining forces on which to rely. Both Guignon and Calhoun discuss the focus inward in authenticity and integrity.
Even with the independence and freedom of thought, the world around us greatly affects our thoughts. One of the major faults seen in the philosophy of integrity is “this understanding of integrity as a personal virtue, guarding one's integrity must be largely self-protective” (Calhoun 253). Authenticity as well seeks to “[pull] back from your entanglements in social game-playing and going with the flow so that you can get in touch with your real, innermost self” (Guignon 146). Modern philosophy unhealthy and inaccurately wants us all to cut the connections and separate the world form ourselves.
However, we are not in a closed system nor are we passive. Yet, removing the self creates the impression that by being authentic or having integrity, we have finally achieved a different sphere from the world. In this different sphere, striving for results does not involve the “outside” world. Calhoun presents counter examples from our judgments of other’s integrities noting in one case, “integrity here seems tightly connected to viewing oneself as a member of an evaluating community and to caring about what that community endorses” (Calhoun 254). Integrity can mean being true to the outside world in many forms including a direct community, an extended nation, the human species, or even for some all the living creatures man is interconnected with on planet Earth. If integrity can be based on these outside factors, the self is also based on all these surroundings. Even this is to passive an approach, Guignon continues by declaring that “to be fully authentic is to recognize the need to be constantly vigilant in one’s society, to be engaged in political action aimed at preserving and reinforcing a way of life that allows for such worthy personal life projects as that of authenticity” (Guignon 162). Upon our shoulders is not only the weight of defining ourselves but also defining the world around us, especially given man’s prominence on the planet.
For better or for worse, individuals are not alone. Working at Marin AIDS Project, I have seen run ups against the system. If the populations attempt to support the poor through medical aid and food stamps, it is seen as socially responsible. However, leaving post-pubescent young-adults with abstinence only education feeds our citizens into these special programs and is morally irresponsible. Using AIDS as an example of immoral based actions which are sounds from the “self” view but not the “non-self” view, one can see many donors who contribute to AIDS organizations across the world but vote for legislation which often foils the very efforts of the organizations they claim to support, major examples for HIV/AIDS include the cutting of public health services of those with the disease, the underfunding or elimination of testing programs, foreign policies which lead to further instability in HIV prevalent areas, and the move to abstinence only education which increases high risk behaviors as well as the social stigma.
Yet, I do not want to say that not caring deeply enough and following issues closely is the only error in expressing authenticity. One individual recounted a story of his ex-wife trying to but a ranch in Nevada to serve as a wild horse refuge. (Wild horses in Nevada are sterilized in a state program to try to reduce or eliminate the population. Wild horses effect both ranching and native wildlife, some of which has been further endangered by increasing human presence in the state.) Yet, this man was on government aid programs with multiple health problems, and the ex-wife would sell the home they owned in the state to pay for her work in Nevada. Is it moral to confront these skewed priorities, to ask the downtrodden to abandon convictions and get their lives together first? It certainly is accepted to tell middle-class Americans to do just that from changing education plans when college comes during a recession or judge a mother who does not vaccinate her child. Is it condescension or guilt which discourages our judgment of these people in the same fashion? Rather than feeling the actions of the ex-wife authentic or socially progressive, I felt them selfish, misguided, and leeching. This type of blind dedication to a cause without taking in social or practical concerns, “non-self” aspects, even when seen as efforts towards a helpful cause, illustrated to me the dangers of a disconnect between personal wants and true, ethical authenticity and integrity.
We want to feel part of the solution, but both common modern ideals of authenticity and integrity promote ideas of uncompromised, “right answer” pursuits in a multifaceted world in which sometime the most ethical, authentic solutions are ones in which the self is left behind.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.