When we look at examples of “the kind of disagreement where the struggle is not to agree but just to understand,” it becomes a matter of how we can express a thought to others (47). The warping of ideas is not often because we have different values but rather because we have different perceptions and perspectives. Because of these different points at with which we approach a problem, often the reasoning and motivation for action scatters in many different unique directions. Education, learning, and curiosity are all important aspects of humanity. Yet, explaining why one does or does not attend college can range from greed, to security, to passion, to laziness, to fear, etc.
While the book is written for a general audience, the general audience in our society is heavily impacted and controlled by science and logic. In a world based off of science and logic, saying “it is often much clearer to us what we should do than why” is any oxymoron (63). To act requires a motivation, a stimuli which can be registered as a call to movement, change, and response, a why. Reductionism spread across almost all generations of scientific theory is based on this principle. If an apple falls from the tree, there must be a reason even if not apparent immediately. If there is a social change as well, there must a reason if not apparent immediately. While these occurrences may not be obvious to the item being acted upon, apple or person, the first because its lack of a central nervous system, the second because of his or her lack of outside and historical perspective, there are always forces behind them. “Efforts to justify what we have done-or what we plan to do-are typically made up after the event, rationalizations of what we have decided intuitively” implies that intuitively our brain is not rational (72). Yet, we are adapted to make decisions based of complex patterns about which we are constantly gaining more information; this item will help, this action will hurt, these are the risks involved, these are the possible results. Many times our intuition is better since it takes into account more facets of an occurrence than we would categorize as important for that decision logically. “Reasoning…comes not when we are going on in the usual way, but when we are thinking about change” (73). The reasoning discussed is about changing the intuitive response or reprogramming ourselves.
I disagree with Appiah in that I believe to understand each other the why has more impact, more potential understanding than any what could ever have. The what could be a short term foundation for discussions while the why rests an ultimate vehicle for by which we can establish judgment across cultures. These lead back to the question of whether motivation has an impact on ethics, which I have no final decision about at this point. Does motivation have an impact on understanding? Yes. Does motivation have an impact on living in harmony? No, a perfect example is that “our political coexistence depends on being able to agree about practices while disagreeing about their justification” (70). I do not believe we can take motivation out of all discussion in the pursuit of common ground.
We interact. As interacting changes our actions, our beliefs, understand one another better, or question the “usual,” it is not due to some greater force, “even the cleverest people are not easily shifted by reason alone,” yet the other things an argument might appeal to, mainly emotions, are all logical responses programmed to balance the individual and the society allowing for the best possible partnership. Greed and empathy come from our brains, not society, and are logical responses ingrained. “If the machinery of the mind is the same everywhere,” then do we really have a conscious choice? (94) Yet, I cannot believe we are solely at the fate of our programming. This is where our imagination and creativity comes in. We must inspire, expand, and promote imagination within our daily lives for fear of losing ourselves not to reason, since reason is an important part of every process, but to stagnant reason in which input does not lead to our adaptation, our becoming cosmopolitans. Building in the scientific community is often portrayed as lacking in imagination and creativity, as being an area grounded and petrified by logic. Yet, this is a hasty and one sided assessment. It misses several important aspects of being a human being. As a human being and a scientist, we do not only observe and rationalize our world.
Appiah approaches science as a stagnant philosophy. Yet, science too is reflecting what people are discovering organically through their daily lives, everything is connected. Emergent properties come from the interaction of parts, making a cumulative sum greater than the individual. To advance further in our technology and medicine, we are coming to more understand the differences in people, molecules, cells, and how that contributes to the greater whole. This trend is not due to an impulse to make everything whole but rather a logical revelation that everything was whole to begin with, only man has taken it apart.
The reading this week has led me down a rabbit hole of the role of logic, and thus science in its basic tenant, in the world. Sorry about the jumbled thoughts; I feel passionate about this discussion. If I continued, I believe I might end up with a bungled manifesto.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.