Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Human Culture

I grew up in Minneapolis, attending inner city public schools where I was constantly surrounded by all sorts of different cultures. I spent much of my childhood as the “white girl.” I would wish many things: I wished I could find some magical lotion that would erase my freckles and darken my skin, I wished my hair would turn curly and darken and that I could have fuller lips and a less pointy nose. I thought all of these things would make my life so much easier and maybe they would have. But I am thankful I was able to be the different looking girl that still fit in, in her own strange way. From that experience I now know what it’s like to be different than others, but I also learned that even in our differences I was similar to everyone I went to school with. In Cosmopolitanism, Appiah says, “We do not need, have never needed, settled community, a homogeneous system of values, in order to have a home” (113). In many ways this is how I feel about my upbringing. I was surrounded by many value systems, and this in many ways was better.

When people hear my last name ‘McMurchie’ and meet my family full of blue eyed, freckled, blonde and red headed people, they immediately assume I am Northern European. Of course this assumption is in part correct, but I’m so much more than that. The first true beauty in life is that we are all different: yes my family eats lefse and celebrates St. Lucia day, but my dad also cooks Ethiopian food, because our Ethiopian neighbors introduced us to it. The second true beauty in life is that though we are different, we are also the same. We have a “shared ethics,” and there are common human universals, which I learned first hand from my experiences growing up.

Appiah says: “Talk of cultural patrimony ends up embracing the sort of hyper-stringent doctrine of property rights that we normally associate with international capital” (130). We can’t patent our cultures: they overlap, like my traditional culture overlaps with “American” culture and the culture of those I went to school with. I think if I were to choose, I would identify myself as a member of the human culture. I have been too “culturally contaminated” (as have most of us) to identify with one particular something. Appiah says there is no cultural purity and it is an oxymoron. I’m happy about that, because I would not want to be eating lefse all the time.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.