Tuesday, November 9, 2010

Interconnectedness

In the first few pages of Outcasts United, Clarkston, Georgia fits the description of a small southern town trying to maintain its identity in the midst of cultural and economic change. Even with the generalizations Clarkston residents give themselves, it is hard not to identify with them: within a few decades, the demographics of Clarkston changed from those "typical [of a] small southern town, conservative and white" to the point where "one-third of Clarkston's population was foreign-born" (p. 34, 36). Understandably, a Clarkston resident who saw their small, independent community go through over development and saturation with immigrants is entitled to feel a level of displacement. On the other hand, the incoming refugees were literally displaced from their homelands, many of whom waited for years in foreign countries and refugee camps to have the right to live in a free community. As with Bienvenue's family, the speed from which many refugees traveled from refugee camps to America was disproportionate with the amount of time they had struggled: "it was as if the family had been beamed magically from one world to another; they had little feeling for the miles traveled, the continents or oceans crossed, or the time elapsed" (p. 72). Coming to America did not just mean picking up the traits of southerners, but also relinquishing the ghosts of their past.

I found myself torn between loyalties in this reading, struggling to unite my desire for communal autonomy with the need for cultural diversity. I value Paradise Foods and Delano Markets as much as Clarkston residents value Thriftown, and it is comforting to walk down the street and know that the guitarist busking on the corner of A Street or the woman walking out of Starbucks with bluetooth surgically attached to her ear are both characteristically Marin. At the same time, San Rafael would not resemble the town I know without the Asian Market across from Whole Foods, Tibetain Culture House on Forth Street, and my favorite fast food place on the planet, Sonoma Taco Shop.

Outcasts United, by Warren St. John, explored the next step of authenticity -- the interconnectedness of individual selves in a community. St. John makes clear that "top down efforts to impose contact and understanding between various groups were likely to fail" by shedding light on the complexity of Clarkstons' cultural prejudice and ultimately how the government and law enforcement were unable to stay impartial (p. 184). The only option for Clarkston was to unify from the bottom-up through interpersonal relationships; they could not be forced or contrived because "connecting was something that individuals would have to accomplish organically and on their own" (p. 184). Such relationships came out of mutual need and benefit, like the integration of foreign foods into Thriftown's stock, or the change of Clarkston Baptist Church to an international community of believers. Those relationships gave both subsets of the community reason to identify on base levels, as mothers, consumers, children, worshipers, and sports enthusiasts; they also provided a reason for "acknowledgement of interdependence that takes into account various group identities" (p. 185). By realizing that their individual differences could be a collective asset, the people of Clarkston were able to unite around shared aspects of their identities.

Big Brothers Big Sisters has given me a lot of hope, not only for myself, but for my community. When I first moved to Marin as a teenager I felt, in some ways, trapped between two worlds. There were different value systems and slang words, ways of dressing and ways of acting, that caught me off guard; working with children at Laurel Dell Elementary gave me a broader context in which to put such a conflict of interests. Many children who have immigrated or are born of immigrant parents have a hard time assimilating to American culture, feeling "neither here nor there, betwixt and between all fixed points of classification" (p. 221). Like many of the "Littles" in Big Brothers Big Sisters of the North Bay's Youth4Youth program, I still struggle between my familial and cultural identity in everyday ways; thankfully, BBBS provides a format where individual relationships are the focus. "Bigs" and "Littles" are able to talk about their conflicts, joys, and worries, and have the opportunity to become united in their commonalities. There are relationships in the program that don't work out, and pairs which are eventually separated, but because of the emphasis on one on one mentoring relationships both the mentor and the mentee are able to decide what they want to make of their time together. Community building is only successful when the community is willing to be built, and being able to work with a non-profit that understands the importance of interconnectedness is extremely motivating in Marin, where it can be easier to avoid difference than to embrace it.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.