Since the beginning of human time, peoples of the world have been at war with each other. There has never been a point where there was complete peace and harmony in the world; many religions state that this will never happen until the end of time when judgment day comes. This constant human strife has been blamed on various aspects that govern humanity. However, in "Towards Transcultural Ethic in a Multicultural World" In Suk Cha states that violence is not caused by fear of the other since "we humans share too much in common with each other in our societies"(5) One could say that all humans are basically brothers. In order to find peace in the world we must acknowledge the fact that we need live with and in companionship with others. In his book Cosmopolitanism Kwame Anthony Appiah brings up the opposing force to cosmopolitans. Neofundamentalists or counter-cosmopolitans think that there is a universal truth and ethic that does not identify with any religion or culture. That is, except for theirs. They believe that everyone should agree with their view of how the world should be. If they don’t, violence follows. There exists a saying that goes "if you don’t want to be my brother, I will smash your skull in"(145). This is considers a malign or damaging form of universalism. In theory universalism should be the best thing for human kinds. It should create a utopia where we all respect the same universal ethic that keeps us at peace with one another. That type, and other non radical forms of universalism, can be considered benign, and striving for the genuine good of the world. The reason, it seems to me, that it is so difficult to achieve this universal ethic is that we are all so different; which brings us back to cosmopolitanism.
The other thing that Appiah discusses in these chapters is the concept of cultural contamination. In my mind I see it more as cultural evolution. The "contamination" part exists when one culture is influenced by another and adopts some new customs and makes changes to old ones. To me this sounds like the natural process that evolves cultures to change with the times. The advantage that comes from a culture that enriches itself with others is that you most likely already live a cosmopolitan life "enriched by literature, art, and film that comes from many places, and that contains influences from many more"(113).
Thankfully I cannot relate the violence that can sometimes result from opposing universalism to my service learning. However I can see cultural contamination in my daily life. In the end, I do live in America. The United States is considered a melting pot of cultures, traditions, and values. We have shaped our nation in response to the different influences that have affected us. If you ask any American what they are their answer will most likely go something like a list of various nationalities that span across the globe. The fact that we are so diverse gives us a leg up in the quest to being cosmopolitans that understand and accept all cultures and strive to live civilly and socially with all.
-Ilaria Guerra
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.