Caring is one of the simplest human emotions that is present in all of us. It can be as powerful as deep love and as minimal as taking an interest. At whatever level it may be expressed, caring about other people in a worldly sense is a most definitely a cosmopolitan idea. However we tend to care most about the people that are close to us like our family, our friends, and those individuals we interact closely with every day. What we find hard to do is to care about a stranger. We have no personal attachment to them, it seems as if there is nothing in common between us, and it is hard to imagine ourselves caring about that other person. Is it then really possible to embrace the cosmopolitan ideal of caring for strangers?
In his book Cosmopolitanism, Kwame Anthony Appiah states that it is “not that we cant take a moral interest in strangers, but that the interest is bound to be abstract, lacking in the warmth and power that comes from shared identity”(98). A shared identity, like what we have discussed in previous books, is what brings strangers together. Whether it is a shared preference or a common trait, people feel a magnetic pull towards others that share their same identity and tend to migrate in that direction. Therefore the secret is to find among the millions of strangers, the things we have in common.
Every summer hundreds of ballet companies open their door to a flood of young aspiring dancers that come to learn the art of ballet in their studios. I have attended four different dance summer intensives in the past and each has brought me together with girls and boys from all over the country and world that come from different families, upbringings, communities, and religions. We are forced to live together for over a month and spend just about every waking minute in each others company. One would think that putting so many strangers in one place like that would be a recipe for disaster but in fact, I have made lasting relationships with many of the people I have met at those programs. What makes such a situation work, is the fact that we have dance in common. For many of us, dance is our life and we care about it more than anything. Therefore it is easy to care about another person that cares about the same things you do; it's somewhat like a cycle of caring. Like Appiah says “we care only about people with whom we share an identity”(98). I am a dancer, she is a dancer, we can get along and I can appreciate her and eventually care about her because we most likely also share other morals and ideals.
That is a fairly simplified example because such programs obviously attract people who like the same activity. It is more difficult to find things in common with strangers off the street or even just your neighbors that you only see once in a blue moon when you are unpacking the groceries from the car and they are walking their dog. Appiah identifies the key to caring about stranger to be conversation and communication. “The points of entry to cross-cultural conversations are things that are shared by those who are in the conversation”(97). Talking to others is the only way that we can learn about the other person and find those commonalities that are sometimes not apparent on the surface so that the end goal can be reached: “we can make sense of each other in the end”(99).
In my Service-Learning, I have seen Janna make that leap across the “stranger” boundary and try to find common ground with the outreach mothers in our program. Yes they have the fact that they are both mothers of twins in common, but many of them come from very different cultural backgrounds and have little in common with Janna, or Amy and I for that matter. What I have witnessed is Janna trying to talk to the parents for the sake of understanding them as human being better and to be able to learn from their experiences and their struggles in order to help them in the best way she can. We found in our conversation with one lady that one of her relatives was actually living in the same city in Southern Californian that I am from; that small seemingly unimportant connection brought more trust in the interaction and allowed us to get closer to her because she saw that we cared about getting to know who she was as a person.
“It is hard, though, to resist the evidence that, starting with our common biology and the shared problems of the human situation (and granted that we may also share cultural traits because of our common origins), human societies have ended up having many deep thing in common.”(96).
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.