Monday, November 8, 2010

Alien

As an immigrant to the United States, a legal "alien," and a multicultural and ethnical young woman, I have often found myself to be a "victim" of the system here. But what's worse, I think, than becoming a victim to something alterable and divorced of myself, is becoming lost in my sense of my own identity. Like the refugees and immigrants in Outcasts United, I have far too often asked myself, "where is home?"

In every country I have ever lived in or visited, I have never felt like I have really fit in. In India I was the white girl. In Singapore I was the half-blood Chinese girl. In the US I am the half Asian girl with the cool British accent. I have always felt defined by my geographic location and where I am as opposed to who I feel myself to really BE. But perhaps this lack of firm grounding is a beautiful consequence in the fondue of our global community. With the help of technology, education, and other forces, we are becoming even more and more of a melting pot of cultures, with people of all races dispersed throughout the world. But what happens when you don't know who you are or what you want to let the world see of you? Or what if the world you are squeezed into doesn't want to see multiple sides of you? Like the kids of the Fugees, "the hardest moments [come] when [we are] expected to be entirely one or the other" (222). How can we reconcile and bring into harmony the many facets of mixed cultures and races, even within individuals?

This to me was made acutely aware when I came to understand "The American Dream." As in Outcasts United, most people who move to the States view this nation as a goldmine of opportunities and potential wealth and prosperity to be had. America is the "land of the free" where anything is possible. As much as this is true, I have unfortunately come to see that it can also be a lie, and I can pinpoint one of this nation's major flaws to be that of lack of acceptance. Like Scipio's story in Outcasts United perfectly illustrates, it is human nature to fear what we don't know. Ignorance is not bliss, it is terror and rebellion. When the people we are supposed to trust, like the police department, don't even respect our differences or backgrounds, how are we to ever really achieve a sound and logical immigration system, let alone firm community structure?

I think that Vertovec's "super-diversity" is at work here, but is not being treated with the excitement and acceptance that it should come with. If we know that "top-down efforts to impose contact and understanding between various groups [are] likely to fail," and "connecting [is] something that individuals would have to accomplish organically and on their own" (184), then why do we continue to ignore the problem? Why are we not confronting the confrontations between "natives" and "immigrants," "blacks" and "whites," "old" and "new"? I think that it's beautiful how diverse we are as a nation, and how much we can subsequently learn from each other. But does everyone? In my experiencing and witnessing and now reading, I unfortunately think not.

Outcasts United has painted a picture through several moving, saddening, and inspiring stories compiled into one neat volume. As an immigrant I feel for these people, and understand how alien and different life here is (For me too, "commuting [to work or school or the mall] - an hour each direction, no less - was an alien concept" (229) when I first moved to the States). And even in acknowledging similarities between people and peoples who come from totally different backgrounds is at least a small step forward towards the end goal we need so many years to aspire for.


Phillipa Armes

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.