Saturday, November 13, 2010

Prompt for Cosmopolitansim-xi-44

It is important to hold in mind that what Appiah is outlining in these first few chapters has to do with the tension in modern society between absolutism and relativism in the way we understand moral values. He is not promoting either view but suggesting that a cosmopolitan approach may be one way to walk the tightrope between the view that certain actions are absolutely right or wrong, regardless of other contexts or particulars and a relativist view that holds the that knowledge, truth, and morality exist in relation to culture, society, or historical context, and are not absolute.
Meaning, that while we may have many differences in morals and values, across cultures and, as individuals, we must be able to identify some shared universal values of what it means to be a humane human if we are to co-exist in an increasingly plural society.
The introduction is important as he begins to lay out his overarching questions. In the first chapter he gives us the metaphor of the shattered mirror and the example of Burton to explore some of the complexities, nuances, and issues regarding our relationship to cultures and values that are different than our own. In the the second chapter, he discusses the ways in which the cultural relativism of anthropology, in which social science prescribed an "objective" view in order to study and learn about other traditions and practices without comparison or judgment has also led to a pervasive moral relativism that implies that we can't judge the values and practices of others because they are subjective and not grounded in "fact". He argues that this is a view that disregards the "fact" that values have meaning because they are shared. Our moral vocabulary is not the "possession of a solitary individual." Instead, the "concept of kindness, or cruelty, enshrines a kind of social consensus" (28). In this way, Appiah, begins to lay out his argument that, "there are some values that are, and should be, universal, just as there are lots of values that are, and must be local" (xxi).
Pull the thread that interests you to better understand Appiah's points. If possible, use your service experience to illustrate.
Also, go here to read recent Appiah's recent NYTime's piece, The Art of Social Change

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.