Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Moving Together

Appiah simply states, "Above all, relationships are changing" (Appiah 103). Appiah recognizes the sometimes negative aspects of this truth, but, more importantly, he acknowledges that relationships must be open to change to encourage cosmopolitanism and the shaping of new lives. It is an impossibility to actively attempt to keep members of a particular culture locked into that tradition. People must be allowed alternatives, and cultures should be left to shift as change naturally comes, not meticulously preserved. Suk Cha believes that all societies have come into some sort of cultural exchange with one another. Appiah says, "The point is that people in each place make their own uses even of the most famous global commodities" (113). There are certain aspects of society that are nearly universal in their existence, but individual cultures remain through the specific treatment of these universal aspects. Cosmopolitanism and a kind of homogeneity can exist smoothly along side cultural exchange.
Appiah calls for an awareness of the suffering of others and the need for a moral obligation to all neighbors (no matter how distant), but also recognizes this as a tricky subject. Why should I care what happens to a complete stranger? Why should I sacrifice what I have to better someone else's life? Though these sound like shallow questions, they are more than viable. Appiah suggests, "Cosmopolitanism is about intelligence and curiosity as well as engagement...It involves seeing not just a suffering body but a wasted human life" (168). Using more than purely moral emotion, cosmopolitans must realize their cross-cultural obligations through reasoning and knowledge of the effects, risks, and outcomes.
The 211 phone service Nick and I have been helping these past months is a true example of Appiah's point. Of course, the United Way is not responsible for these strangers who are in need of help, but they have realized through intelligent thinking that it would be beneficial for the whole of our society to aid them in their struggle.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.