Tuesday, November 23, 2010

Keeping DIalogue Alive

Sorry, I didn't see the prompt...

In these chapters of Kwame Anthony Appiah’s book Cosmopolitan, he draws the line between respecting other cultures and fearing to engage them in constructive dialogue. To be a cosmopolitan one must recognize that other societies contain differing viewpoints, practices, beliefs, and traditions. However, it is not appropriate to merely accept every culture’s beliefs simply because you are not a member of their culture. Appiah stresses inter-cultural dialogue between societies that challenges the belief systems and traditions of cultures. Through this dialogue each culture may benefit through insight or change. In these chapters Appiah specifically discusses the complexities of language between cultures as well as the issue of disagreement.

Appiah says, “…we can fail to share a vocabulary of evaluation; we can give the same vocabulary different interpretations; and we can give the same values different weights” (Appiah 66). Although communication across cultures is nearly always a possibility on a surface level, it can become increasingly difficult once a discussion begins regarding the importance, value, or meaning in aspects of the respective cultures. Nevertheless, it is the job of the cosmopolitan to find a middle ground within the complexities of language on which to solve the social dilemmas that naturally arise from the different lifestyles of foreign societies.

Despite the difficulties of communication, Appiah reasons that it is an important part of any process of change. He states, “…when it comes to change. What moves people is often not an argument from a principle, not a long discussion about values, but just a gradually acquired new way of seeing things” (73). In order for one culture to even be aware that an alternate lifestyle exists, however, one culture must reach out and begin a dialogue that shares information. The change will not be quick or drastic, at least inmost cases, but this mirrors the natural way of life and will be the least likely method to incur harm or displeasure among the people. Observing a practice you believe to be wrong and stepping in at the last minute expecting change is a destructive fantasy. Cross-cultural communication must be enacted early on to allow cultures insight into different beliefs and opinions.

Appiah recognizes the difficult of inter-cultural dialogue, especially when dealing with a culture’s traditions and values. However, this should not deter the cosmopolitan from reaching out and exploring other cultures while also steadily introducing their own beliefs. This kind of gradual communication will open the world up to accept one another and act together for the benefit of all.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.