Tuesday, November 16, 2010

I Thought Scientists Were Amoral

“Do onto others as you would have others due onto to you” or “love they neighbor” can no longer be considered simple commandments in societies which constantly intersect and blur cultural boundaries. Appiah states “each person you know about and can affect is someone to whom you have responsibilities” (xiii). The problem is and will continue to be that I have become interconnected with most if not all people on this planet, which as far as we know means all people in existence and is continually increasing. I can affect people across the world based on the products I buy, the way I get to school, and what I choose to pursue after undergraduate studies. Further, many people in the world outside the United States as well as in are effected by my voting behavior which in turn affects foreign policy, economic policy, military conflicts, immigration, etc. I have the resources to know about a large majority of groups of people on this Earth and thus have a responsibility to each and every one in all my actions, and “no local loyalty can ever justify forgetting that each human being has responsibilities to every other” (xvi). The idea of universal community, responsibility, and empathy is empowering and beautiful; it also means that the weight of the world is, in a way, literally on every modern day citizen’s shoulders.
In the trend of expansion and inclusion of people in society, we begin to perceive social structure, though never perfect, as having an infinite capacity for complexity and evolution. The problem however is that each individual to an ever increasing extent does not have a comparable capacity for complexity and evolution. While we can learn, grow, and revise our beliefs and knowledge, I believe that the world is too broad in scope for one person to know all things about every issue facing humanity nonetheless be all things to all people. At some point we must rely on society, though we need not do so blindly and with total faith. If “what it’s reasonable for you to think…depends on what ideas you already have,” drawing on the vast communal experiences and ideas should improve your world understanding and lead to more reasonable responses compared to drawing only on your individual experiences (39). Further, in cases of cause of effect, “we have developed institutions that can allow ordinary human being to develop, test, and refine their ideas” (42). If these institutions are effective, each individual can contribute to the greater questioning and revision of society. This idea that society is imperfect marks an improvement over theocracies or dictatorships, which are based on an absolute truth.
Yet, the above societal outlook is also based to an extent upon an absolute truth, that there is an explanation, a cause, behind every aspect of the universe. The universe is logical and therefore there is a definable driving force behind every occurrence. The universe is logical, and the gaps and flaws in our knowledge, and thus our actions, stem only from the slow progress of the human mind and our inability to test every theory completely due to technological constraints, which can and have decreased over time. This idea of the “answer” behind everything can lead one to assume that the concept of logical also applies to human beings. If I am happy, my life does not harm others, and I contribute to a sustainable and improving social structure, then my life must be closer to the answer than another’s which I perceive to not have these characteristics or at least having them to a lesser extent. Yet, “because there are so many human possibilities worth exploring, we neither expect nor desire that every person or every society should converge on a single mode of life,” the way we hope that all molecules converge into a single set of constantly followed laws (xv).
Since my responsibility is to all humanity, since humanity is diverse with no one set of laws dictating actions or morality in those actions, and since individual and societal knowledge is incomplete, there is no absolute answer in how to act morally. This is why “we enter every conversation-whether with neighbors or with strangers-without the promise of final agreement” and in the scientific view point, though known for positivism, this divergence and conflict is good, natural, and perhaps the largest step towards true morality we as a species have taken in modern times (44).
While interesting in theory, saying there is no right answer and no clear way to change the world makes it much harder to fight the “good fight” for your beliefs when those beliefs, while executed in completely morality, may lead to detrimental and unintended consequences. For example, the longer the lifespan, the healthier the individual living with HIV, and the less the stigma that comes with the disease, the larger the interaction an infected individual has with the world, and the greater the potential risk of infecting new individuals. HIV treatment also removes funds from prevention programs as well as all other programs in the budget, often including education and other aspects of health care. This is further exacerbated by the problem that HIV/AIDS is not curable and thus increasing the lifespan means increasing the cost of treatment for every infection. How do you balance taking the money for a child’s education and giving it to their parent to treat his or her fatal, long term illness? How about taking money from the education budget of Kansas and using it to pay for treatments for an IV drug user in San Francisco? How about raising the price of that drug, purchased with government aid, to support the loss of income due to having the sell the drug more cheaply to third world nations? Other ethical issues come up often in health care, such as is vaccinating a child the personal choice of the parent when it presents a very real risk to every other child in the community? These are all issues within our own culture, which do not involve relativism. To expand our moral rules across cultural lines would exacerbate the complexities already faced. To these issues, we cannot say there is a right answer, so we cannot judge a society which has the opposite answer without fully taking into account both the intentions and end results of these actions.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.