Saturday, September 17, 2011

Mini-lecture/Prompt for Text Reflection:Ethics of Authenticity 1-4 and "Know Yourself" from Flesh in the Age of Reason

(As these are such complex pieces, here is a bit of my interpretation to help ground you in the principles that are being presented here)

Both these pieces go into both the depth and breadth regarding the issues related to the myth of the individual. Building on the historical overview that I gave in class, "Know Yourself" provides a vivid and energetic romp through some of the social, intellectual, philosophical, and political movements that have fed the dynamic tension that exists in the modern sense of self and the myth of individualism that Taylor delves into in The Ethics of Authenticity. In my own interpretation, this is the tension between two ideals of self:

1) the project of "self-fulfillment" the idea that we have one fixed authentic, cores self that can be reached through much inner exploration and stripping away of societal conditioning--As Taylor writes (note that he is saying this is a flawed notion that puts undue pressure on our own self-creation. He is not saying that we should all "conform" but that the notion that we must do everything on our own in order to not conform is problematic):

Each person has his or her own "measure" is his way of putting it. . . There is a certain way of being human that is my way. I am called upon to live my life in this way, and not in imitation of anyone else's. But this gives a new importance to being true to myself. If I am not, I miss the point of my life, I miss what being human is for me.This is a powerful moral ideal that has come down to us, It accords crucial moral importance to a kind of contract with myself, with my own inner nature, which it sees as in danger of being lost, partly through the pressures toward outward conformity, but also because in taking an instrumental stance to myself, I may have lost the capacity to listen to this inner voice. And then it greatly increases the importance of this self contact by introducing the principle of originality: each of our voices has something of its own to say. Now only should I not fit my life to the demands of external conformity: I can't even find the model to live by outside myself. I can only find it within. (Taylor, 29-29)

and
2) our inherent recognition that we are part of a greater reality and we are interdependent/connected in ways that also define our identity. There is no "I" without "we" and that the result of this tension has been a perverse tipping towards the idea that being an independent, autonomous individual is somehow literally possible:

I can define my identity only against the background of things that matter. But to bracket out history, nature, society, the demands of solidarity, everything but what I find in myself, would be to eliminate all candidates for what matters. Only if I exist in a world in which history, or the demands of nature, or the needs of my fellow human beings, or the duties of citizenship, or the call of God, or something else of this order matters crucially, can I define an identity for myself that is not trivial. Authenticity is not the enemy of demands that emanate from beyond the self; it supposes such demands. (Taylor, 40-41)

Meaning, and as Taylor depicts in a few different ways, we associate authenticity with the first overly literal understanding of individualism. This view degrades the ways in which we are all shaped, formed, conditioned by many different elements that are necessarily part of what it means to be human:

it would take a great deal of effort, and probably many wrenching break ups, to prevent our id entity being formed by the people we love. Consider what we mean by 'identity.' It is "who" we are, 'where we're coming from.' As such it is the background against which our tastes and desires and opinions and aspirations make sense. If some of the things I value most are accessible to me only in relation to the person I love, then she becomes internal to my identity. (Taylor, 34)

We are not "created" or "grown" in a clinical test tube, therefore we are impacted by all kinds of environmental, historical, and biological factors not of our own making and usually beyond our control. At the same time, as Ray Porter notes, we have tended to see the self-project as an either/or proposition--either we chose the modern road of self-fulfillment or we chose the more traditional, often religious path of self-denial in order to transcend the self and merge with the greater, cosmic reality.
The point of both pieces is that neither and both are true--as human beings we have both drives--to be a unique, creative individual and to be part of the greater reality which we inherently know we are already part of! It is the denial of our "partness" and the seeking of wholeness/authenticity as if we could ever be literally non-dependent that may create many of the existential and moral crises that we see today, including the culture of narcissism, alienation, and dangerous relativism that Taylor outlines.
These are big, complex concepts but crucial to understanding our own psychic make-up and some of the ways we have been "taught" to think of ourselves that may compromise our capacity for ethical being and actually cause us greater fragmentation and alienation--as both pieces also describe. Please use this reflection as a chance to engage both readings and further unpack these ideas for yourself.

2 comments:

  1. Julia, I am feeling uncomfortable by the statement that you made about the "denial of our partness and the seeking of wholeness that is the potential cause of many of the psychopathologies that are seen today". I have clinical depression that can only be fully managed by taking an antidepressant. Talk therapy is not enough. I am fully aware of the fact that I have hopes and dreams of my own, and that I want/need to be a positive part of the society around me. The hope I have for myself is to be a part of a team that develops better psychoactive medications, which I feel will benefit both myself and the society I live in. My depression is caused by a chemical imbalance of two vital neurotransimtters in the brain- not by an imbalance of my authentic self and the need to be a contributing member of society. Without the extra boost of neurotransmitters, I could run the risk of ending up in a psychiatric hospital. I don't take my medication only because I feel that I need it- I take it because without it, I probably would not be here right now.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I do think that Charles Taylor’s quote “it would take a great deal of effort, and probably many wrenching break ups, to prevent our identity being formed by the people we love…If some of the things I value most are accessible to me only in relation to the person I love, then she becomes internal to my identity” (Taylor, 34) contains some truths. Like it or not, people are defined/identified by those they associate with. So if a relationship ceases to continue, then the identities of the people involved shift. I wouldn’t say that their individual identity changes completely, but certain aspects do change.

    At the same time, the ended relationship will always remain a part of the people involved. Although sometimes we think it’d be nice or easier to forget, that doesn’t seem to happen all that often. I think Taylor is correct in saying that “she becomes internal to my identity” (Taylor, 34) because when you are that close to someone, they do become a part of your identity and who you are. The effect that one person had on another never completely goes away, our subconscious holds onto our experiences and influences future actions.

    Roy Porter said “the individual’s mind [is] a unique storeroom of consciousness” (Porter, 6) and I would argue he is right. The brain stores everything that we as humans are. Without our brain we couldn’t be the individuals that we all strive to be, but also without environmental factors like the relationships we experience, we might evolve differently. Everything seems to have some sort of connection to everything else, be it a connection we make leads to an opportunity we hadn’t known before or the fact that we evolved the way we did because of a relationship we had with someone else. Our individual selves as well as the person we become because of our relationships shapes who we ultimately become.

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.