After reading a few of the answers placed on the blog, I am finding it hard to come up with an answer that is very original, so I apologize if I repeat anything that was already said. In the first response, Julia Hand mentioned that one’s life experience may motivate them to acts of kindness. In contrast, the second blog by Camille describes it as a need to relate to others that motivates one to kindness. I feel that both are good arguments and are very true, but both of these statements can also go the opposite direction and describe what motivates violence and destruction. Deo could have just as easily taken what he saw in Burundi and turned it into a reason to become violent, or to seek revenge, but instead he chose the path of kindness and generosity. The need to relate to people can lead to violence as well. If one grows up surrounded by violence, then perhaps violence will be how they relate to others. Deo could have joined the Tutsi Army and fought back, but clearly that thought was never even an option as it was never mentioned throughout the book. In fact, Deo never really speaks of wanting to fight back, even out of anger from what he saw.
So what is it that really drives to action? I think that it largely comes down to desperation. As pessimistic as it sounds, desperation of different levels can drive us to do things that are either beneficial or detrimental to ourselves and those around us.
In the beginning of Part 2, Deo describes reading a book that he felt explored the problems with medicine that were occurring in most third world countries including Burundi, but it wasn’t just about the diseases. He discussed the fact that these were diseases “that most of those patients wouldn’t have contracted in the first place if they hadn’t been desperately poor,” (Kidder 152). In this case, it was the fact that the people were desperately poor that they were becoming victims of diseases such as TB and AIDS, but they didn’t really have any choice. We see how disparity effects people’s choices later on, when violence erupts. It was the fact that one majority was desperately poor and suffering, that they rose to action and violence.
I liked how Noelle put it in her response, stating, “The key difference is that the motives for violence are emotions centered around oneself while the motives for kindness are centered around others.” (par. 4). Although it could be argued that originally the violence occurred in Burundi in order to help the majority, I think her statement is largely true. We could take a step further and say that is desperation in one’s own life can lead to violence while the desperation of a community can lead to kindness. It could be said that growing up in Burundi, watching a friend die at a very young age while thinking “‘What can I do, what can I do?’” (Kidder 85) is what inspired Deo to build the clinic. He saw desperation in his country, his community, his neighbors, and even his own family. This desperation was intense enough that even after leaving them and seeing the violence that they could commit, he decided to return to help. Desperation for food causes a homeless person to either beg or rob, while seeing another person’s hunger may cause us to donate to a food drive. Desperation may cause a bullied students to become violent towards themselves or the bully, but seeing another person being bullied may cause us to reach out to them or stand up for them. Whether you take desperation as a negative term or not, it is clear that it influences people’s actions. Whether the actions are positive or negative largely depends on who is to benefit- oneself, or the community.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.