Initially I was going to write about how much I disliked and disagreed with Richard Norman on his book On Humanism because I was reading through the lens of a conservative Catholic. However, while I'm not entirely sure that I fully understand what I have read, I found the material to be thought provoking. I was immediately intrigued by the concept that humanism is a rejection of religious belief. As Baron d'Holbach stated "Man is the work of Nature: he is submitted to her laws: he cannot deliver himself from them: nor can he step beyond them even in thought" (11). This quote spoke to me because man in the setting of nature defines humanity. Humans are vulnerable. Humans are vulnerable to the surroundings around them, to their physical inclinations, to the natural feelings that we cannot help but feel. Human nature is the essence of humanity. That is not to say that because we are compelled by nature around us we are not subject to a higher power. I noticed that humanism and religion were referred to as two separate and different things when in fact I find they relate to each other. Humanity sets the stage for religion. Because of all our faults and shortcomings we are not divine. That's what makes the spiritual connection with one's god so real. One is willing to leave the natural world behind and make a sacrifice. For example, September 11 was an act of religion. The hijackers were willing to make the ultimate sacrifice because they thought they were abondoning humanity. They thought they were fighting through the grasps of a physical world in order to be with a higher power, to do something for what they perceived was the greater good.
Another concept that stuck out to me was towards the end when Norman said "It makes little sense to talk of huiman beings either as naturally good or as inherently evil. We know the terrible things which human beings are capable of doing in certain conditions. We also know the acts of heroism..." (24). I believe it is a futile argument trying to prove that humans are "essentially good" at heart or born "inherently evil." I think that because each human is a wild card is also what defines us as being human. No one really knows what each other human is capable of or what drove someone to act a certain way or do a certain thing. Each person holds a subjective view of what guides them.
What I really took from the reading is humanism is not an alternative to religion. Humanism does not take the place of religion. Rather, humanism is a close relative of religion. Both things offer explanations of who compells humans to act as they do.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.