Monday, September 5, 2011

Twisted Nature - J. Kiefer O'Sullivan

I believe kindness and generosity are a fundamental part of human nature, and that it is society that warps individuals into selfishness, inaction, and apathy. Sharing has always been essential to the survival of our species. If our hunter gatherer ancestors didn’t return with the food they had caught and had shared it with the rest of the tribe, the cohesion and overall health of the tribe would suffer, and the members would be less likely to survive as a whole. New scientific research is now even discovering an “altruism gene” present among a wide variety of living creatures, from small insects to chimpanzees. Members of a group who selflessly share their food when they have some to spare contribute to the overall health and success of the group, and therefore also the individuals that are a part of it. Nature is not as “dog eat dog” as we once thought. Of course, one can then extrapolate what this looks like in humanity: generosity, charity, philanthropy.

As humans, I believe we are destined from birth to grow up and contribute to society, to help and share so that we all may be at peace. However, the society we have constructed does not reward those who share this belief. Society demands that we take what we can get, whenever we can get it, and savour it for ourselves. We live in a world of need. We are forced to believe that there is just not enough to go around and that if we don’t take what we can get, somebody else will. Now, because of this belief, it has become the truth, it has become the world we live it. We are made to help, but taught not to by society. I believe this is the reason why most of humanity is suffering.

Individuals are motivated towards evil, not by nature, but through a warping of their natural selves. This can be seen many times in Deo’s story. One phrase that really resonated with me that I feel illustrates this is in the way Deo interprets the PIH’s message: “Prevent people from suffering! Don’t wait for people to feel like their lives are not worth living. Once they feel that way, how are they going to feel about another person’s life?” (155). Suffering begets suffering, evil begets evil. It creates something akin to a positive feedback loop, the more suffering exists, the more suffering will exist. Essentially good people commit evil acts because they get caught up in this cycle. I feel Deo illustrates this well when he is quoted speaking about the living conditions in his country: “How are you going to think right? With pain everywhere. So it’s been really hard to blame people all the time. They were not themselves. They were something else” (187).

I believe humans are benevolent creatures, but suffering is what changes us, for worse or for better.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.