Monday, September 5, 2011

The Polar Nature of Humanity

“What motivates individuals and collectives to acts of kindness/generosity rather than violence/destruction? How does Deo’s story speak to these universal themes in particular ways?”

More than a story of success against great hardships, the chronicle of Deo’s life offers insight into the expanse of human nature. Closer to the point, Deo’s experiences include extreme acts of kindness as well as despicable examples of violence. I believe that kind acts, such as those experienced by Deo, are the product of humanity’s innate compassion whereas violent experiences result when individual desires overrule a person’s inherit ability to care about others.

There are many instances where people showed great goodness by assisting Deo. Muhammad takes Deo to where he lives and helps Deo find a job, even though Deo is a complete stranger (11-18). Sharon McKenna works tirelessly to try to find Deo a good place to live (56). Nancy and Charlie Wolf let Deo live with them for free, even though they really don’t know him that well (67). Perhaps the greatest show of kindness came from the Hutu mother, who likely risked her life to help Deo get into the refugee camp (126-129). In all of these cases, people make sacrifices to help Deo with no concrete benefits for themselves.

In stark contrast to the acts of kindness, Deo’s life story involved a significant amount of violence. He grew up in a school system where the children were frequently found at fault and therefore beat (81). He witnessed refugees being led away to their deaths and women being taken away to be raped (132). Of course, the largest source of violence for Deo was the attempted genocide of the Tutsis by the Hutus. In all of this violence, the morality of humans was being overruled by other aims. In the case of the beatings, the teachers were trying to enforce strict discipline amongst the students. The refugees were probably murdered on the off chance that they were Tutsi. Women refugees were raped to satisfy the soldiers’ desire for power and lust. The entire war was caused by anger that stemmed from prejudice and ethnic inequality.

It is my belief that humans are naturally altruistic and can frequently sacrifice to help others, as evidenced by Deo’s encounters. It is only when desires and emotions overpower this fundamental morality that people resort to great violence.


- Christopher Galbick

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.