I could not agree more with Taylor's three malaises: Individualism is the cause of 1) The loss of meaning in life; 2) Instrumental Reasoning in order to gain the greatest profit with the least amount of work; and 3) Lack of Freedom due to the industrial and technological society which we live in. I will focus on the first malaise, for I feel it is the most significant.
What is it that makes our lives meaningful? Personally, I believe it is the relationships we maintain and create with other people and having a true impact in the world in any way. However, in today's society people are taught to focus on themselves first, and only themselves. Why give some homeless guy on the street your leftovers from a restaurant when you can eat it the next day for lunch instead of buying something else? Why give your friend a ride to their house at night when you have to focus on studying for your huge test the following morning? According to Taylor, "People lost the broader vision because they focussed on their individual lives" (Taylor 4). The society in which we live in is a dog-eat-dog world where competition is key. By concentrating on oneself and one's own success, we tend to ignore the world around us. A real life and personal example of this would be the experience of many college students and our connection with world events. Most of us are more concerned with finishing our homework, hanging out with friends, and even updating our facebooks that we don't even watch the news or read news articles. It is not that we don't care about the world around us, but it is the fact that we care more about meeting the needs of our own lives. Taylor acknowledges the fact that, although we do lose meaning in particular aspects of life due to our individualism, "The moral ideal behind self-fulfilment is that of being true to oneself, in a specifically modern understanding of that term" (Taylor 15). The way we act is directly correlated to us being ourselves in our own society, in a manner in which we know and are familiar with. However in order to be more satisfied with life in general, it would be logical to attempt to find meaning in all aspects of life and not just the parts directly concerning us.
Porter takes a different view in his writing and focuses on the evolution and development of "the self." Individualism directly stems from humanism, which was a literary and scholarly movement which "rejected the dogma of the miserable sinner required to abase himself before a jealous God, and began to take delight in man himself as the apex of creation, the master of nature, the wonder of the world" (Porter 3). Once the spotlight was switched from God to man, it would make sense that it would eventually switch again from man to self. I never understood this concept until after reading Porter's introduction, and it honestly boggles my mind. Thinking about the massive amounts of events, people, writings, and time required to change the ideology of the masses is truly humbling.
A quote Porter cited in his writing stood out to me in particular; "the child is the father of the man" (Porter 7). At first glance this statement didn't make sense to me, however when taken in context of what was being discussed it was extremely profound. Porter was talking about John Locke's philosophy of man not being born with innate ideas, but acquiring knowledge solely through experience. Accepting that the child is the father of the man is accepting that our experience growing up throughout life has made us into the people we are at this very moment. Our personalities and attributes were not specifically chosen for us; we make ourselves into who we are in the future, and therefore we are in control of ourselves. And since I am in control of myself, it is necessary for me to focus on myself in order to grow and understand who I am as an individual; because only I can do that. If worst comes to worse and one feels as if they have no control of the events occurring in life, I think both Taylor and Porter would agree with Mom's advise to "just be yourself" because we cannot control our lives, but we can control who we are in life.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.