Tuesday, September 13, 2011

A New Perspective on Religion vs. Art

While I was reading On Humanism, by Richard Norman, I found myself continuously coming into conflict, then agreement with what was written. In the first chapter, Norman outlines his ideas and seeks to give his reader definitions of the terms that he would use throughout the chapters. In additions, he gave a historical look at how humanism came about, using quotes and excerpts from early humanists to define humanism as it evolved. The fifth chapter describes spirituality and how secular humanity is just as fulfilling as spirituality and religion. Norman allows us to follow his ideology by comparing secular and nonsecular ideas while giving specific examples of each.


When I first began reading, I intensely disliked the chapter, despite the fact that I am not very religious and actually agreed with most of the ideas. W. It seemed throughout that Norman is deeming it impossible to be both religious and a humanist. For instance, in the first few pages of chapter one, Norman dissects an excerpt from Jean-Paul Satre, a french philosopher from the 20th century, saying that the portion of text, “focuses on the idea that human beings can make of themselves what they choose through their exercise of freedom.” (Norman 6). I completely agree with this statement, but he then later states that Satre and another philosopher, Bertrand Russell, “share a humanism which is a belief in the ‘human’ in opposition to a belief in a god,” (7). It seems that by saying this, Norman has decided that being religious takes away freedom of choice, but most religions are simply giving a moral guideline, not taking away this freedom. Moreover, Norman describes how some believe that “religion has blighted people’s lives, imposing restrictions and inhibitions in the name of divine commands,” (16). What I don’t understand is why does it matter where the restrictions or guidelines have come from? One cannot claim that the restrictions of the Ten Commandments are not viable because they are supposedly “divine commands,” as opposed to a law which is current and written by humans, that essentially says the same thing; for example, both say that it is unlawful to murder. Restrictions, both positive and negative, are posed not only by religion, but by society, and personal values that have been created through experiences in one’s life. Despite this small conflict, I found that I liked most of what Norman wrote.


What I found the most interesting were his ideas on how to live life fully without religion. As was discussed in chapter 5, many people believe that “life without religion and religious ‘spirituality’ is somehow impoverished.” (Norman 139). There are many things in life, however, that are empowering, meaningful, and fulfilling without religion. Things such as relationships with other humans, success or discovery, and art. Art as he says, “[enables] us to make sense of our lives, in a way which nothing else can.”(142). Art opens our eyes and challenges our ideas. It allows us to use words or some sort of medium to express what we think, feel, see, and even hear. Furthermore it allows us to share all of this with others.


Ultimately, religion and art both bring people together and provide answers to some of life’s questions. I don’t necessarily think that art could replace religion on a larger scale, but for those seeking to find answers without religion, art is a definite alternative.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.