Sunday, September 11, 2011

Responsibility -Whitney Myers

Of the various explanations provided, Karl Marx’s explanation of humanism most resonated with my understanding of how people function. This is not to say that I am a proponent of communism as it has appeared in the world so far, but Marx’s concept of humanism focuses on humans working for the benefit of humans and the world, together, using humanity’s power actively. If “work can become, for all, the objective expression of essential human powers” (13) rather than a tool used to gain financial benefits (as it is in a capitalist society), then there is a much greater chance that humanity can use that power as a unit, with the purpose of community welfare. Marx says, “It is the genuine solution of the antagonism between man and nature and between man and man” (13). Marx also refers to humanism as “the positive side of atheism” (13). He seems to see atheism as negative in that it removes the possibility of a power divine enough to dictate what is good, what is bad, and what humans should be accountable for, whereas humanism is positive in that it teaches what is essentially human without relying on a supernatural power, which may or may not exist.

Secular humanism, like that of which Marx approves, is useful when one has not been brought up in a particularly religious way. Answers found by many in the examination of religion and divinity are not as readily acceptable when divinity and logic do not coincide. Norman says that humanism might even be considered “as an alternative to religious belief” (14) providing the “practical philosophy of life” (14) previously determined by religion. I am not as opposed to the existence of divinity as Norman appears to be, but I wouldn’t dismiss humanism whether I completely subscribed to religion or not. It seems to make sense, even if there is a divine power, to hold human beings responsible for human actions.

Norman cites conflicts generally attributed to religion, such as “the medieval Crusades… Christian imperialism…the continuing conflict between religious groups… and the destructive fanaticism of Christian and Muslim and Hindu fundamentalists” (17) in his argument against the validity of religion, then dismisses them because an equal list can be found of non-religious conflicts. In the argument against religion I would also dismiss these as evidence, but because those conflicts are the result of human action, not divine. Just because a group of people belief in a certain divine being, and commit a horrible action based on their interpretation of that divine being doesn’t mean that that being is responsible for the people’s actions. According to humanism, human responsibility for human action should mean that, as those conflicts are a result of human action, not the fault of a divine being, they cannot be held as evidence against divinity. Whether or not a divine being exists, it doesn’t seem logical to hold it accountable for a human being’s interpretation of that divine being or of the world. In addition to providing a context in which humans can determine shared morals and values, humanism can be valuable as a restriction on the use of divinity in justifying human action. Humans are to blame for human action, whether they cite divinity as the instigator of that action or not.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.