Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Self

The reading that really resonated with me was The Ethics of Authenticity by Charles Taylor. I felt that Flesh in the Age of Reason by Ray Porter was mainly historical references to the creation of individualism while Charles Taylor talked about the causes of individualism. I would however like to focus on the first cause, according to Taylor, about individualism.

Individualism is defined as favoring freedom of action for individuals over collective control. I agree with Taylor in that “we live in a world where people have a right to choose for themselves their own pattern of life, to decide in conscience what convictions to espouse, to determine the shape of their lives in a whole host of ways that their ancestors couldn't control” (2). But do we really think for ourselves or are we taught to think in a certain way?

I think that being “yourself” entirely in society isn’t something done by every individual. The thought of even nearing that is abolished by other self-inhibiting thoughts. When Taylor says “indeed, many think that it is still incomplete, that economic arrangement or patterns of family life, or traditional notions of hierarchy, still restrict too much our freedom to be ourselves” (2). I feel that these causes are merely underneath the umbrella, so to speak, of society. By this, I mean that society, through media, technology, politics, bureaucracy, and economics, restricts our freedom. The main cause, I would say, is society in itself and these branches hanging are what feeds society in achieving this goal of making us believe what they want us to believe. I don’t, however, believe that society wants to necessarily make mankind into this individualistic person but people tend to follow what society says because its society who said it firstly and secondly, it tends to become the norm after a while.

As I read “people were often locked into a given place, a role and station that was properly theirs and from which it was almost un-thinkable to deviate. Modern freedom came about through the discrediting of such orders”, this reminded me of Allegory of the Cave, Plato’s work (3). As Plato had wrote, people are taught to do what they do because society has made it so. When the chained people escape, they are foreign to the “real” world, which in their case happens to be fantasy, because till now they have seen only shadows and those shadows became the truth. This is one way in which people associate self with society’s norms. In other cases, people tend to associate self with higher beings, “People used to see themselves as part of a larger order. In some cases, this was a cosmic order, a ‘great chain of Being,’ in which humans figured in their proper place along with angels, heavenly bodies, and our fellow earthly creatures” (3). Taylor goes on to show how in a way, this was good and in a way, it was bad but it sooner or later came to the point where “things lost some of their magic” (3).

Lastly, I do want to touch on the fact that society is growing, perhaps at a higher rate than ever before. And as we grow, we begin to lose sight of what we thought we were (self). If we look now at life, there are so many issues that there is barely time to dwell on self and when we do dwell on self, its labeled as acts of selfishness. There are now too many thoughts but not enough time to think about those thoughts. Each day becomes impossible because day by day something new always arises, thereby inhibiting our thought process, making us follow what is there.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.