Monday, September 12, 2011

Humanism: Mankind's Responsibility

Prompt:  How are you able to follow Norman's description of this broad concept of humanism? What raises questions or resonates with you?


Richard Norman's "On Humanism" is an in depth analysis of the concept of humanism.  In all honesty, I never understood the term "humanism" until I read Norman's writings, and even now I am still uncertain on particular aspects of it.  Humanism is a frame of thought in which man is the central figure.  In other words, "Humanism, then, in the sense in which I shall understand it, is an attempt to think about how we should live without religion (15)" according to Norman.  He discusses the idea that humans use religion as a crutch to support their moral character, and that many believe that without it complete chaos would ensue.  However humanists argue that the world does not need religion to in order to be "good" because humans have the power to reason and choose their own actions.  Mankind has been granted the gift of free choice; whether this gift was given to us by God or nature no one truly knows.  However in humanism, what matters is not the source of the gift, but how one uses it.
There is not one specific definition of humanism; in fact it consists of countless versions.  Norman illustrates this fact by discussing the humanist theories of several different people and highlighting the point that each theory is unique with one solid grounding point: man is in control of himself.  Personally, reading about the various types of humanist thought helped me gain a better grasp on the concept of humanism itself.  The phrase which stood out to me the most while reading is that "...human beings have no fixed nature but can make of themselves what they choose through their exercises of freedom" (6).  We are free to make our own decisions and control the path of our own lives; however it is our responsibility to make the decisions which make ourselves happy without harming others.  More often than not our selfishness tends to take over and influence the decisions we make, but this in itself is human nature.  With our ability to think and reason comes a duty to use our power wisely, and it is the test of humanity to fulfill that duty.  The fifth chapter of Norman's book discusses how religion and science are thought to be continuously butting heads.  He writes that instead of stubbornly picking one side of the argument and sticking to that viewpoint, humanism can aid in being the common ground between religion and science.  Why must we have to pick only one belief?  Why should someone who chooses to put his or her complete faith in religion be ridiculed as being in denial of reality?  On the other side of the fence, why should someone who places his or her complete faith in science be scorned and thought to be damned to hell for not believing in a higher being?  In this view I completely agree with the author and his standpoint, however I find it difficult to agree with much else.
Perhaps it is the manner of his explanations or his aloof attitude but I had a very hard time reading the fifth chapter of Norman's book without being slightly annoyed by his arrogant tone.  His manner of writing seemed very one-sided and, for lack of a better word, uppity.  He continually stated that he did not intend to put down the religious viewpoint, however to me it seemed like he simply said that in order to be less controversial.  Norman discussed the fact that chimpanzee's, no matter how intellectual they are, could never understand Newton's Laws because they are limited by nature.  I agree that this is probably true, however we don't know this.  
After reading Norman's writings, the one thought which resonates within me is the fact that we, as human beings, assume that we are superior to all other creatures because we are intelligent and have the ability to reason.  Since the beginning of humanity, it has always been assumed that mankind were superior to animals.  Religious evidence is provided by the book of Genesis in the Bible and scientific evidence is provided by the evolutionary theory; a humanist common ground.  However, do we really know that we are better than all other animals?  Last time I checked humans have been killing, and continue to kill each other over food and territory, like many creatures of the animal kingdom.  Humans also kill each other over selfishness, greed, lust, and ego; unlike the creatures of the animal kingdom.  Does that make us superior or inferior?

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.