Sunday, September 4, 2011

Desperation -Whitney Myers

I have been told, in various forms, at various times, in relation to various events, that a society has erupted into violence and destruction because that society’s groups, be they religiously, economically, or ethnically based, experienced desperate levels of inequality. Desperation drove the conflict, because the situation that those groups found themselves in became so dire that violent change became a viable option. While the idea of violence as a logical choice seems hopelessly impossible for me to comprehend, something that could never become acceptable to me, the idea of such complete desperation also seems incomprehensible. It seems to me that I cannot condemn a society or group or person for resorting to means I cannot imagine when they suffer pain I cannot imagine.

Deo has a similar explanation for the violence, but cites misery and pain as the root cause of the conflict in Burundi and Rwanda. “How are you going to think right? With pain everywhere. So it’s been really hard to blame the people who have been slaughtering each other, though I do blame people all the time. They were not themselves. They were something else” (187). Like me, Deo finds it difficult to hold those in desperate pain accountable for resorting to violence. Desperate levels of pain or misery, or even economic desperation, is something I have never felt, and so cannot understand, but Deo has felt desperation, and believes that desperation has the capacity to change a person to the extent that they cannot be completely responsible for their violent actions.

Following the logic above, the Hutus and Tutsis experienced so much ethnic discrimination and economic inequality that they became desperate, and therefore accepted violence as an acceptable means to deal with their desperation. I wonder, in that case, what separates one person’s desperation from another’s? Though Deo’s situation was desperate, he did not pick up a machete and join the brutality, as others did. He cannot have been so much better off than those instigating the violence, and yet, according the explanation above, desperation should determine violence. So there must be further factors determining who will adopt violence as a tool for change.

Whether people react more like Deo did or more like those who joined the milita men did may be influenced by Deo’s concept of “distracting pain with pain” (208). Deo says “pains exist in layers, with the most excruciating at the top obscuring the pains beneath” (209). This idea seems to have merit to me, and to have broad application, as Deo said. Though the application most apparent to me is the childhood practice of pinching the area next to a mosquito bite in order to alleviate the itch by obscuring it with the pain of the pinch, it does seem, as Deo says, to have a much larger psychological application. “So many years of paying attention to the topmost pain of war, he felt, had left many of his people numb to all the rest” (209). Perhaps Deo did not react to his desperation by picking up a machete and attacking because he was relatively unexposed to violence before the genocide, and had not become numb to brutality on the level of the militias. Perhaps, becoming numb to violence through layer upon layer of pain will predispose a person in a desperate situation to react in a violent way.

In order to motivate a group or person toward kindness and generosity rather than violence, they must be removed from desperate situations that can trigger violent action. Whether they react to the desperation like Deo did or like those who joined the militia men did, if they are not placed in desperate situations, then they will not have reason to resort to violent means to escape the situation. Deo’s clinic is an excellent example of alleviation of desperation leading to a more peaceful community. “It seemed to Deo that Kigutu was becoming a ‘neutral ground,’ a place where Tutsis from the mountains and Hutus from the lakeside could mingle without fear” (259). When Deo assisted in lessening the suffering in the community, those in the community became less desperate, and therefore less likely to resort to violence.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.