Norman tries to show that humanism is a bigger umbrella, not mutually exclusive to either view, and may also be useful in finding more shared ground between the scientific and religious views.
How are you able to follow Norman's description of this broad concept of humanism? What raises questions or resonates with you? Use quotes and make connections within the text to better unpack these ideas before relating them back to you or your experience (which you can do, but you don't have to!).
The article in itself was a little hard to follow. He does a lot of jumping from one topic to the next and because he seems all over the place I did not get a one big perspective of humanism. What I gathered from the introduction is that there are many forms of humanism. That humanism is the focus on human nature and what is the topic for debate is whether or not there is a divine power orchestrating a person’s life. Instead of a God or higher power controlling a person each human has free will and decides his or her actions accordingly. The concept of humanism started back in the days of Enlightenment where thinkers were skeptical about religious belief. A classic from the Enlightenment was given in the article, written by Baron d’Holbach, stated that “man is a part of nature (11)”. Because a statement like Holbach’s was not uncommon among Enlightenment thinkers humanism developed with a negative view of religion. To support the previous idea, the author of this book stated that, “Humanism is an attempt to think about how we should live without religion (15).”
The author chose to defend the view of secular humanism in his book which translates humanism an alternative to religious belief. Examples of this concept are found in atheism and agnosticism. Agnostics are impartial to whether or not God exists and atheists completely banish the idea of a God. The negative aspect of atheism can be a pessimistic view of the world. In other words, “because there is no God, life is utterly bleak and meaningless and there is nothing left for us but despair (18).” That is not humanism. Humanism is the belief that human beings can have a good life without religion as a “crutch.” What interested me in this chapter was that the author brings up the point that a persons’ humanity can be lost in extreme situations. The example for this is a book written from a survivor of the holocaust. In concentration camps, they dehumanized the inmates which transferred as a positive because the inmates would then fight for their humanity. What is typically overlooked is the dehumanization that the guards and the officers had to go through in order to treat the inmates this way. In order to treat a fellow human the way they did they must first dehumanize themselves which is a very powerful concept when you sit and think about it.
One thing I found I really agreed with the author is the statement that in humanism there is an acceptance of mystery. The belief is that “the human species is not a species set apart, with a privileged status, made in the image of God, but is like every other species a product of biological history (134).” It furthers the argument by stating that we are limited by perceptions and intelligence and that is why the universe will stay a mystery. In that mysterious nature, we as humans are fragile. We must recognize the fact that we are vulnerable to circumstances and our failings. One failing brought up in the chapter is that we focus on finding meaning but instead it is “these elusive moments when things come together (146)” that there is meaning. The message in this quote is that we learn from the things that we can’t expect and because of that we are fragile to the events that occur in our lives. Once you accept yourself you can live and understand the world fully.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.