Tuesday, September 6, 2011

Generosity and Its Limitations

“What motivates individuals and collectives to acts of kindness/generosity rather than violence/destruction? How does Deo’s story speak to these universal themes in particular ways?”

As stated by Thomas Hobbes in Leviathan, “man is evil”. I, personally, don’t believe mankind to be all too generous. I would want to believe that but it is upon the person to decide whether they want to show any generosity or not. And even generosity has its own limitations.
I believe that for the most part, people help to get something out of it in return whether it be direct or indirect. For example, as Deo landed in what he thought was New York, he was in Ireland. He met this lady, who also spoke French and who he thought he could trust,“to answer felt dangerous. She wasn’t just a stranger, she was ajournalist...she seemed like a friend, his only friend on this journey” (9). But to his surprise, she turned out to be after his story rather than the person who he was, “he spotted her again...she was standing in another line, pretending not to notice him” (9). We can see by his first experience that people are not entirely what they seem. In this case, we can see that that lady was more keen to know the effects of the genocide rather than know the person at all.
Later throughout the book, it was stated that, “convention, of course, has everything to do with children...not to have children was in itself a rather unconventional act” (166). This basically states that people were more or less persuaded to have children as a way to fit the “norm” in society. Because of this, in a way, Deo was treated as a child. When he first met Muhammed, he gave him a place to stay, a job for him to work at and taught him how to get around the city (10-14). Muhammed didn’t even bother to ask any details , instead, he just wanted to just help him out in one way or another. Soon enough, Deo was walking on his “two feet”, so- to-speak. Muhammed was more or less his “father” as well as his “uncle”, duo roles. In another instance, we meet SharonMcKenna. Instantly, we can see she takes a high interest in Deo and his world as she is always behind his back like a mother would be. Going back, we can see that Shannon is highly generous and always in the spirit of giving. In Part 2 Gusimbura, Kidder visits her and sees the files to Deo’s living situation and how she took notes and called every agency to find him a place to stay in (176). We also see that after Charlie and Nancy met Deo for the first time, Nancy wasn’t all too pleased but soon enough, Charlie told Sharon, “Bring him down” (170). From here, Deo was treated as their child and as a college student under Charlie and Nancy’s care. There were a number of times when Deo couldn’t sleep at night only to be disturbed by his nightmares of the genocide. Although he had gotten used to the bodies, he still was traumatized by the experience. And we could see that Nancy would be by his side all night, just as a mother would be for support and comfort. As he went off to his universities, he still maintained contact with Nancy and Charlie and from time to time and visited them. They even saw him off every time he went off traveling to Burundi. Even more, they left his room as it was when he left without any changes, the picture of his uncle on one side and of course, the threatening email on the other (165). Evidently, Dr. Farmer also became a sort of “mentor” in Deo’s life as they too spent all night talking. “I wish you could fly with me to Haiti” were Dr. Farmer’s words to Deo as he dropped him off at the airport. These words could only express the sentiments that Dr. Farmer had. But even grander were the words of this lady in Dr. Farmer’s organization, who said “if anyone gets up and walks out now, I’m going to kill ‘em. No one did” (159).
In any case, as Deo got the love and care he deserved in this world, everyone who helped him gained a sense of fulfillment and understanding for themselves and the outside world. As Nancy states, “I believe it is human to hope to find order and connection between one’s soul and the world outside” (168). I can say that they were humane in their actions towards Deo. All in all, regardless of the situations at hand, “i still believe people are good at heart” (Diary of Anne Frank), which always explains why Deo went back to his homeland countless number of times, in times of danger and in times of ease.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.