I actually would like to take a small amount of my reflection to say how life is truly serendipitous. This semester in particular, I have taken many different courses but all of them have essentially helped my knowledge of one subject grow. An example, for my psychology major we are asked to take theories of personality which teaches us the history of psychology and the important philosophers that helped guide us to the psychology we have today. It was in that class that I was introduced to humanism and then to further concrete my knowledge we were given the topic in our Service Learning class.
Now onto the assignment, both The Ethics of Authenticity and Flesh in the Age of Reason have a similar focus on individualism. Flesh in the Age of Reason is more of a historical view while The Ethics of Authenticity goes into the flaws of individualism. It is the view of Porter that individualism is the struggle to realize “self” and can be immortalized in the words of Polonius in Hamlet, “this above all, to thine own self be true (3).” The idea of individualism dates back to the philosophers, such as Plato and Socrates, who believed in “an inner goodness, truth and sacred goodness (4).” The church however saw self-exploration as an act against the church. Followers of the church must obey the Commandments and by partaking in self-exploration that follower was committing a sin. A rule of self-denial was what the church wanted which was completely against the ideal of self-actualization. During the Middle Ages, when the church was the ruling body the concept of self-denial was widely accepted by its followers but when the Martin Luther challenged the Church and Protestantism began the power of the church diminished. Protestants promoted the religious experience as a personal one and that the use of introspection could be used to contact God. The time period of the Enlightenment and Romanticism brought forth a lot of ideas of “self-centredness in the modern psyche (9)” and the “impassioned quest for the ultimate truth (11).” These two key ideas were what set the stage for Freud’s theory of an unconscious world. Freud’s discovery shaped the self-actualization process into a journey to truly find out oneself.
The development of a “self” also has its negative effects on society which leads perfectly into Charles Taylor’s, The Ethics of Authenticity. It is Taylor’s argument that individualism, a primary view of the modern day world, has created a sense of helplessness. The individual in the modern society “no longer has a sense of higher purpose, of something worth dying for (4).” Essentially we have narrowed our view by developing a “narcissistic, permissive society (4).” As a person of the modern age, and a firm believer in the expression of an individual, I am prone to be against this view. I completely agree that there are flaws in our society (such as “putting dollar assessments on human lives (6)”) and that we can be egocentric but that is what makes us human. In order to survive, there has to be some element of thinking about yourself but to say that an individualistic society is purely egotistical is appalling. Taylor uses the philosophy of Aristotle and says that “human nature, and that an understanding of this will show certain ways of life to be right and wrong (19)” is wrong. I am only a college student but I have learned the difference between right and wrong and it is my decision on whether to do good deeds or bad deeds. Taylor goes on to state that moderns, “can [only] define identity against the background of things that matter (40).” In order to exist, a modern must be defined by those around them is false. I do believe that experience does influence us in growth but it is not what defines as a person. It is the will of the moderns to survive, even if they are egotistical, that makes us who we are.
-Meghann Jones
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.