For the past few readings we have been discussing the role society plays in our search to be the human. In Everyday Ethics we discussed the separation of the private and public spheres, and in Pedagogy of Freedom the differences between teaching to and teaching with and its role in the greater scheme of society. Now in this second section of Charles Guignon's book On Being Authentic we are confronted with the evolution of the philosophy of individualism in relation to “the formation of the modern worldview”(28). He states that three shifts occurred in the mentality of authenticity the first being the Protestant Reformation, the second being the Scientific Revolution and the third was the concept that society is "man-made" and "anti-natural"(33). All three of these periods in time mark a different understanding of how one should relate the self to society. Guignon attempts to give such understanding in his text, and I will try to relate it to life today.
With the first thinking came the the assumption that “we should never let the affairs of this world concern us too much, for the only issue that really matters for us is our immortal soul and its eternal life”(30). This thinking reenforces the slight detachment from society or rather thinking of “society” as a greater religious family but that the goal of life is to find “personal salvation or the religious individualism”(29). In today's society there is still a large majority of people that believe that the ultimate path to authenticity is the spiritual one that is connected with God. This path however is confronted with the obstacles of living in a modern and technology filled life of instant gratification.
This brings us to the second shift that Guignon discusses which is the Scientific Revolution. This brought on a philosophy that the world should really be defined in the terms of a universe which is a “homogeneous aggregate of material objects in contingent causal interactions”(30). The anthropocentric thinking thus followed as well as the outlook that “there are no boundaries to human mastery over nature”(33). Scientific progress is not achievable without the help of a demanding society, and in addition the split between man and nature decreased the possibility of seclusion of the individual since man was brought together from the absence of nature.
The third shift is an interesting one. It is an extension of the scientific revolution thinking but goes farther to say that not only is society man made but it is anti-natural. This shift actually had the opposite effect of its predecessor; it pushed the people looking for the authentic inner soul away from the unnatural synthetic society. As Guignon puts it “if the social realm is inherently inhuman, the way to humanize it is to be sincere in our dealings with others: we need to say what we mean and mean what we say”(35). Guignon also uses the poetic example of Faustus to explain that though ultimate knowledge and power are tempting pleasures, “what benefits the man to gain the world and lose his soul?”(41). You could say that in this moment in time, many of us are skeptical of the corruptness of society and that we are looking inward to find the better way of life.
In chapter four, Guignon moves on to explore the philosophy of individualism found in the Romantic era. He claims that there are a few factors that were present then that are still present in our contemporary world: the sense that we must recover a sense of wholeness, the conviction that truth is found through listening to ones feelings, and that the self is the the most “real” of them all. It is hard to say how these ideas have affected me or how they have shaped the world I live in because in truth I have not experience the world or myself enough to the point where a retreat inward was necessary. However I can see that some of the ideas that Guignon is talking about have a very real presence in this modern society. Like he stated in the earlier section, the distancing from the natural and “primordial” constitutes in the missing of an essential par to of the human self that is connected with nature, which is the point of recovering the wholeness of being. He states that “we need to listen not to society, but to the voice of nature”(57). In the Romantic mindset, society was keeping us from being whole and nature was the ultimate cure. The environmental movement can be described as a move away from the harmful effects of society to the healthier preservation of our natural world.
Another problem with society, which is a point that Peterson touches on in Everyday Ethics, is that personal feeling are not cultivated nor expressed in the public sphere of society. The creativity that spurs form the feeling that we all posses, is a quality that makes us human and makes up our individual self. Restricting these feelings in the presence of the public to make way for pure research and facts, has brought our society to a cold and detached place. “Your creative activity of self-making is the ultimate source of you own being”(70); return to feelings is a return to the self.
The last concept that Guignon unpacks is the Romantic vision that the self is the “real”. This is a very abstract concept, which I personally have not fully grasped yet, but essentially suggesting that “the authentic self is the individual who can stand alone, shedding all status relations and social entanglements, in order to immerse him- or herself in 'sheer life'”(72). This to me has a very Buddhist ring to it and thus is probably not a philosophy that is adapted by the majority of people. However, realizing that the real is within oneself and should not be sought elsewhere is the core of the argument. These few chapters in the book have been dense with insight and information and the next few indicate further exploration of the role society plays, and has played, in the realm of authenticity.
haha sorry this is soooo long. i got a little carried away haha
ReplyDelete