Through service, education, and the experience of life itself I know that there is no greater way to connect with "the deepest and most eternal part of thy soul" than living in connection to others (p. xi). Though it may seem contradictory to the notion that who we are on the inside shapes our outward appearances and actions, I believe that our environments and culture shape our internal self and ultimately share a dual relationship in determining our authentic self; following this reasoning, authenticity of self and personal growth are dependent on a community which invests in the growth of its members.
Having lived in Marin County for over half a decade and watched classmates and friends fall victim to bullying, depression, drugs, suicide, overdoses, and life-threatening illnesses, I can say that my fight to give children in America a sense of belonging and community through relationship is extremely close to my heart. When I look back on my junior year in high school, the message that I wish I could tell those teenagers who have fallen victim to life's ills and those who did not make it to this day is that they were a part of our collective identity, and they were loved. When I represent Big Brothers Big Sisters at a pageant or an event, I have a vested interest in seeing that children of circumstance have at least one positive, strong relationship in their lives, one that will leave an impression on their personal sense of self and give them a foundation on which to have a positive self image. It is amazing to see what an empowering mentoring relationship can do for a child's self esteem and the effect it can have on their future.
I say this because unlike Charles Guignon and Roy Porter, I do not believe that there are only two ideal focuses for a meaningful life. We, as communal creatures, have goals of "achieving self possession" and "a conception of being part of a wider flow of life" (p. 7). Freud and Plato being at extreme ends of the spectrum, we live in St. Augustine's world whether we like it or not. We all seek a state of moving "inward and upward", understanding ourselves so our lives and positionally in relation to others are fulfilling and meaningful (p. 17). I do not view sacred or cyclical time as a notion of the past, left in Biblical history or precolonial Africa, but as a reflection of the eternal need of humankind for authenticity in their singular and pluralistic identities, and because I honor both I am able to derive meaning from every moment as a deepening of my personal roundedness and authenticity, within this world and within my soul.
Just as a brief note--neither of these authors are actually suggesting that there are only two "ideal focuses for a meaningful life" they are formulating this concept based on the phenomenon itself--that people "tend" to pick one process or the other--to idealize one over the other. The authors are both speaking to this phenomenon, not proposing it.
ReplyDelete