Jean Rostand stated, "science has made us gods even before we are worthy of being men" (Wikiquote.org). With the capacity to understand the world around us, it becomes harder to passively accept a role in the universe as something which continues naturally to form out of chaos. We do not want to be ants and deer, in organized groups only from evolution. Humans are creators, inventors, changers, and the closest thing to gods on this planet. This outlook “begins to see society as something anti-natural, as a fortuitous product of human agreements” (33). Society is no longer an aspect of our species, a core of humanity, but rather a “gentleman’s agreement” made logically to help us advance. Society is a tool manipulated by choice rather than an inherent aspect of being man. If society is only a tool, there is no deeper connection or role to play in its advancement beyond the point where it provides us benefit. Service learning would be valuable only in addressing problems where solutions potentially could raise the standard of leaving of the group and inherently oneself as a member of that society.
A break between the natural world and the created world, meaning human society and infrastructure, mirrors a break in our self view between our natural selves and our created selves. When this split occurs, “values are found not ‘out there’ in the world of living beings, but rather ‘in here,’ in the minds of humans” (50). If the world is a completely rational and logical set up which can be remade “according to a rational plan,” then answers come only in the form of greater understanding of cause and effect of events in the world (33). Existence and the universe defined as the interaction of matter does not lend itself to replace the role of religion as it fades out. Matter and science emphasizes that we are not unique or chosen. Spiritual transcendence is not possible since disconnecting and looking beyond factual evidence is a marker of denial and delusion. There is nothing more than the interactions of matter. Even our empathy can be looked at as an evolutionary development to try to strengthen our responses and care to others of a group, to keep us all together and thus better protect our species if not immediately benefitting the individual. With this perspective, we must not become philosophers, ethicists, and humanists; we must become behaviorists and evolutionary biologists.
If “the universe is cold, heartless, mute,” then there is no humanity in it, only reality (42). To bring humanity back into our lives, there must be some “core” to get back to and bring to the front. While “the scientific worldview brings with it a powerful sense of human progress and emancipation,” the sense of connectedness and purpose is removed often leaving individual grasping for reasons “when choice is seen as having no basis other than momentary preference or feeling” (49,44). So, if there is no deep meaning in the world, “the goal of life is to increase pleasure and avoid pain” (50).
This philosophy provides few answers on close inspection since it can be interpreted on multiple levels. One of the major problems with viewing increasing pleasure as a selfish and destructive force is that increasing pleasure long term for the individual almost always involves increasing pleasure for the community as well. To increase the pleasure of discovery, advancement, and thought, other members of the community must be educated, employed, and consulted. Pain as well can be endured reaching far beyond the “momentary preference.” One clear example is that choice of take care of one’s health through daily care, such as good hygiene and exercise, as well as more intense medical treatments such as surgery or physical therapy. Many of the arguments against the scientific line miss the idea that our pleasures and pains are placed within complex contexts over long life spans and treasured social networks. If we do not want to be ants and deer, the ability to reason and use logic to advance ourselves and our communities long term is the important aspect, not the need to control, dominate, and separate our works from those of nature and, in modern movements, those of society.
A reactionist may seek out an authentic life that “is organic, mysterious, dark, and bound up with some greater reality” (75). A gut reaction to finding that complete logic is too hard, too abstract, and too blunt to be the truth. If one cannot find the answers in the physical world, turning in provides a potential respite from having to live under the modern perspectives. This approach leads people to blindly search for answers outside of every fact seen. If there answers “are beyond on the reach of one’s own intelligence,” we can stop fretting about having to break apart and accept facts in the world the way “radical Enlightenment” requires (75).
Circe McDonald
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.