In the second section of On Being Authentic, Guignon discusses the three major events that shifted humans into a modern worldview in the 16th century: the broadening of Christian sects, the advancement of science and the idea that society’s are not natural, but are instead human made. All of these events led to an increase of a sense of dualism, or “outer self “ and “inner-self,” which was also discussed in more detail in Peterson’s book. One thing that really stuck out to me that Guignon said regarding the changes of the 16th century that led to the evolution of moderns was; “ The primary task of humans is seen as gaining knowledge of the external world” (42). As moderns, we are constantly being filled with knowledge and our job is to decide what information we choose to shape us as ethical human beings and change our sense of self.
In chapter four, Guignon discusses philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau who’s contrubitions to self identity are numerous. Rousseau said most things that upset us are caused by “our own making” or due to things that happen in society. To relate to this idea, Guignon says, “Constant reflection and calculative reason distort our nature and tear us away from the simple understanding of right and wrong we have from birth” (56). In other words, due to social conditioning, humans create their own problems. I see this often in society today. For example, the use of ADD medication has more than doubled since the 1960’s. Society allows us to have problems and says that we have problems and why would we not agree with it?
And to conclude my mismatch of ideas, I will end with something Guignon said in chapter three of his book; “If the social realm is inherently inhuman, the way to humanize it is to be sincere in our dealings with others” (35). Society shapes us and we in turn shape it, but in our personal and private dealings with others we must be sincere in order to maintain a “humanness” quality in society.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.