Tuesday, October 19, 2010

Science and Detachment

In chapter 3 of Charles Guignon's "On Being Authentic", he discusses three pivotal historical events that brought focus upon the individual. One of these events was the advancement of modern science in Europe. Previously, nature and the cosmos were seen as creation of God, instilling them with an innate purpose and importance to humankind as fellow creations. However, as knowledge of the world around humans increased it was realized that the structures of nature act independently of humankind, "...with no mysterious or supernatural principles at work anywhere" (31). This idea greatly diminished the importance of emotional and spiritual interaction with nature, and emphasized the individual's ability to view the world objectively.
In order to view the world as a mechanized process, separate from the human experience, one must, "...suspend all the those beliefs, commitments, and concerns that traditionally were seen as definitive of the self" (32). The world must be viewed through scientific abstraction to rightly know your true self. People become "subjects" that experience life against a backdrop of objects and structures of nature that can be fully understood and manipulated. The human is the center of the universe. Instead of emphasizing our roles in nature, our new goal, "...is seen as attaining power and mastery over nature" (33). The ability to gain and utilize knowledge of our surroundings separates us from nature and makes the individual all-important, not his or her place in the world.

In chapter 4, Guignon discusses the criticism of this separation from nature. He says, "There is the feeling that, with the coming of the disenchanted outlook of modernity, a primal unity and wholeness in life has been lost" (50). How can it be the natural state of humans to exist as separate entities from their own home? What has been seen as the underlying importance of life is stripped away by the cold, objective views of science. The true self is not wholly made up of the individual.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.