Sunday, October 10, 2010

Who is What? What is We? Who am I?

Guignon suggests two very different and very distinct ways of defining our purposes in life, posing the "age-old question": "What is the most meaningful and worthwhile life possible for humans?" (Guignon 6-7). The first method, as identified by the author, is "owning oneself, of achieving self-possession" (6). In this psyche, we as humans must have pre-determined and acknowledged that all we need to fully advance in and make the most out of our lives already resides within ourselves; all we need to do is tap into those "resources" (6).

The second idea that Guignon poses is that of "self-loss or releasement" (6). The antithesis of the first approach, the author states that this methodology calls for the total ignorance of the self, and the complete devotion to the greater good. In theory, this approach should bring around a feeling and ideal of "'belongingness' or 'togetherness,' a conception of being part of a wider flow of life rather than being in contention with everyone else in a struggle for self-enhancement" (6).

His two very discernible approaches aside, Guignon brings up a good point in reproducing the human dilemma: "What exactly is this 'inner self' we are supposed to be true to? What does it include and what does it exclude? What if it turns our that this true self includes some fairly nasty - or, even worse, banal - characteristics, traits we would prefer not to think of as really us?" (9). What exactly is it to be human? What is the meaning of life? To what higher purpose do we aspire that validates our existence? What is it to actually know ourselves? According to Guignon, it is "to know above all what your place is in the scheme of things" (13).

Porter's evaluation of our seemingly endless human craving for purpose closely mirrors Guignon's, attributing Guignon's "self-loss" to premodern ideals and his "self-possession" to postmodern ones. Porter reports that it was not until the golden age of Greece that "the first stirrings of true individual consciousness" (Porter 4) came about, a result of thinkers questioning the divine order that had until then ruled all aspects of life. Before these revolutionary thoughts came into fruition, the truths that "self-denial was the supreme good" and "the whole was greater than the part" (5) reigned true, both characteristic of premodern thought.

It is now commonly accepted that Renaissance Italy marked the dawn of man's free-thinking break from "conformity and the Church, taking fearless leaps forward into self-discovery and self-fulfillment" (5). This new way of thinking largely comprised of a leaning towards introspection and the scrutiny of one's own psyche, viewing "salvation [as] a personal pilgrimage" (6) rather than one governed and spelled out by church and state.

These great Renaissance thinkers began to create within the realm of postmodern thinking, different "sects" and varying degrees of individualistic thinking in everyday life, stretching from a "compuls[ive] [] self exposure" (8) to "sensibility" (9) to "self-love" (10) to "sexuality" (12). What all these branches share in common however, is their beginning in the roots of discord towards an all-ruling and powerful ideal of conformity. And though we as a race, and as unique individuals, still struggle with the "'I am that I am'" (16) complex, we have collectively determined that only through self initiated and fueled introspection can we each discover our meaning and purpose.


Phillipa Armes

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.