Tuesday, October 12, 2010

Wherefore art thou, self?

Both writers bring up major trends in the definitions of our true selves in relation to the outside world.  Starting from “all thought-processes being collective” then transitioning to the defiance of the gods seen in ancient Greek philosophies and myths to eventually landing at modern movements seeking answers “not with an understanding of [an individual’s] relation to God, but with his relation to himself,” the trend seen is to move further and further inward as our understanding of the outside world increases (Porter 4, Guignon 2). The trend hints that as the understanding of our surrounds increase, all outside ourselves appear less spiritual, mystical, and important. Further, with our ever greater ability to manipulate our surroundings, people are placed as the central force in the universe.  Once approaching the outside world with a position of power and an increasingly engrained and rigid dedication to logic, one must be moved into the position of an observer and manipulator. Upon finding no inherent god, purpose, or connection with surroundings though, looking inward remains the only respite and hope to find deeper meaning. Given the extreme knowledge base, modern individuals are comfortable with the “heroic vision of man making himself.”
Yet, self-creation and limitless freedom bring up new challenges. Without a template off of which to grow, how can one measure success? If success is only an inner state, can one not think his or herself into a feeling of accomplishment without taking any physical action in the world? To be able to self create, separation from all non-self influences would have to be maintained for fear of simply incorporating engrained aspects of society rather than the “true self”. If we do possess “some real and essential ‘inner self,’” it either must be stagnant or developing (Porter 3). If the self is stagnant, than “enownment” would ultimately lead to some conclusion or result about yourself and an answer to finding individual happiness. If the self is developing however, there is no inherent kernel of truth which to authentic or dedicated too. There is no nub of the person buried but rather a complex perspectives, personalities, and ideas which each can manifest different aspects of ourselves without really resulting in inauthentic existence.
A developing self holds the potential “of becoming something you were not yet-becoming a person who is more than or better than what he or she had been before” (Guignon 3). While religion and professions can and have created the meaning of becoming better than or more than the self, there is no reason in a more secular and independent modern perspective this idea could not be created from the self. An interesting difference between this idea and finding answers in the true self is that from this perspective improvement and achievement does not relate to self-discovery. The path of being better relates to being better in the interaction with the world rather than being more honest or ever being happier. “The highest goal of living, on this view, is to become a new person by becoming responsive to the call of something greater than yourself” (Guignon 8).
Our self-hood leads back to how we define our self-hood. If self-hood is the most poignant and constant driving emotions unique to our personalities, only through the acknowledgment and satisfaction of these drives can happiness and contentment be found. If self-hood is our chosen role in society, perfecting and embodying that role to the fullest and best extent would be the ultimate authenticity. If self-hood is defined by the nature of our interactions, by controlling the world around us can we truly control ourselves and be authentic. There is no definitive answer to what self-hood is since it is an intangible idea under the constraints of language; I wonder if self-hood can only be expressed or defined through action. Authenticity seems to create disconnect between self-hood and physical actions which creates another path away from facing the realities of the world. Self-hood to me is my actions, thoughts, and expressions. There can be no “deeper” me which is hidden from the world and from myself. Seeking it out may only create a false perception of a hidden self. 

Circe McDonald

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.