Both of these readings call into question the notion of "self-hood" and the dual messages that exist about the nature of our "authentic" being and the path to "achieving" that idealized state. Both authors challenge some of the assumptions that we, as moderns, have about what it means to be a unique, autonomous individual.
Porter gives a fascinating historical overview of some of the shifts in our conceptions of self, and the Western presupposition of "some real and essential 'inner self'" ("Know Yourself", 1). He, as does Guignon, notes that "there is no shortage of publicity for a galaxy of styles of self-fulfillment. . . but such nostrum-mongering is set against a backdrop of the erosion of established identities, associated with the disintegration of traditional family patterns, employment, gender roles, education and other social institutions"(16).
Guignon will build the case more slowly throughout the book, while Porter in these few pages gives the historical overview and asks questions to which Guignon will speak in the last chapters of his book.
So, we will be talking more about the broader issues in following weeks, for now, use both texts to unpack what Guignon calls the two ideals, two quite divergent concepts about how we "might answer the age-old question, What is the most meaningful and worthwhile life possible for humans"(On Being Authentic, 6-7). He describes the two ideals--one of "enownment" and the other of "self-emptying and self-abnegation" (7).
Both he and Porter describe some of the historical and intellectual developments that have been the catalysts for these views. What are some of the influences that they note and how do they describe the differences between these different ways of thinking about our self-hood?
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.