"Just be yourself"; these are the words that most of us hear when we ask for advice about a stressful or intimidating situation. This assertion that if one shows the true colors of the "inner self" (Porter, 1) everything in life will be better is an age old belief that is explored in Charles Guignon's book On Being Authentic and Roy Porter's introduction excerpt from his book Flesh in the Age of Reason. Though Guignon gives his critique of some of popular culture's definition on what it means to be authentic and Porter gives a historical narrative of the various stages the philosophy of authenticity has gone through, in both readings two main concepts are being addressed to answer the question "What is the most meaningful and worthwhile life possible for humans"(Guignon, 6-7). The first concept being "enownment" and the other being "self-emptying and self-abnegation" (Guignon, 7). These two ideas on authenticity give insight on the way people and cultures see themselves as authentic beings.
The ideal of enownment focuses on the achievement of self-ownership and works with the assumption that "each individual already contains resources and potentialities"(Guignon, 7) to be the best that one can be. In relation to this ideal Guignon tells us to take it with a grain of salt; he is skeptical about the teachings of modern self help gurus like Dr. Phil and Oprah because though they teach people how to bring out qualities that have always been in them but the motivation has no substance behind it. Porter similarly states that the enownment theory didn’t come to be until later in history with Freud's belief that "there was indeed an inner core truth of the self"(Porter, 14) and also with John Locke's assertion that the mind, self, "begins as white paper, or wax, to be molded and fashioned as one pleases"(Porter 8). The enownment idea in summary relies on individual discovery and is essentially a "superficial and self-serving"(Porter, 15) concept.
On the other hand, the self-emptying idea gives one's quest for authenticity "over to something greater than yourself"(Guignon, 7). It is a more all encompassing theory that puts humans as "parts of a wider cosmic totality"(Guignon, 13) and stresses the right way to be humans, or be authentic, is to direct our orientation to that which is bigger than us like God or a larger life force like Dharma. Porter claimed that during the Romantic era one of the beliefs was that "communing with nature was the way to restore harmony with one's true inner self"(Porter, 10) and that in order to reach autonomy one must "fuse personal development with spiritual destiny"(Porter, 10).
Through history there have been many phases of thinkers and philosophers that have come and put forth their interpretations on what it means to be not only human but a fulfilled human. The inner self is a mysterious and obscure place that human kind has tried to shed light on for years and though countless methods have been discussed, there may never be a right answer to the question "Who are we?".
-Ilaria Guerra
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.