Thursday, April 28, 2011

Precarious Life

“Either you are with us or you’re with the terrorists.” I have heard this quote multiple times. This is the perfect example of the either – or logical fallacy. It deprives us from thinking differently, because to think differently is to be with the “terrorists.” Judith article encourages us to listen and remain open to what others think and to look at possibilities as to why violence like 9/11 occurred. By all means, it does not justify what these “terrorists” did, and it also does not make us responsible for their actions but we are responsible for our actions and make sure it does not happen again. Like Butler stated, “This is not the same as holding the United States exclusively responsible for the violence done within its borders, but it does ask to United States to assume a different kind of responsibility for producing more egalitarian global conditions for equality, sovereignty, and the egalitarian redistribution of resources” (14). It is in our nature to retaliate with violence when someone hurts us or hurt someone we love. Butler suggests that we should first step back and take a different approach and look for the root causes of such violence to prevent from happening again. Instead we didn’t and we still have not. Till this day it haunts me the thousands and thousands of innocent lives that have been lost due to this never-ending war. Yes, we have lost soldiers but we must also remember that we have lost innocent people in different countries in the Middle East.

I love how Butler mentions “collective responsibility.” Like Arendt, Butler wants us to take responsibility for out actions and accept it. This will be the only way we can change our nation. “Our collective responsibility not merely as a nation, but as part of an international community based on a commitment to equality and non-violent cooperation, requires that we ask how these conditions came about, and endeavor to re-create social and political conditions on more sustaining grounds. This means, in part, hearing beyond what we are able to hear” (18)

1 comment:

  1. Is it really in our nature to retaliate? In the movie, "I am", S. Shadiack states the interpretation of Darwin's work over emphasized the aggressiveness of human nature and our natural state is to cooperate and participate together democratically.

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.