Saturday, April 23, 2011

Prompt/Notes for Precarious Life

PLEASE SCROLL TO THE BOTTOM OF THIS POST AS I HAVE ADDED SOME IMPORTANT MATERIAL
Use these points to help you unpack ideas--please make sure that you find a connection to service. Please try to post once and then come back in and engage/comment on another post. Please check back in as I will probably also make comments throughout--so read the comments on posts.


Make sure to notice where Butler identifies issues and presents alternative formulations, often in the form of questions, sometimes as very clear statements.


The rise of anti-intellectualism—what does Butler mean by this/how does she illustrate this phenomenon/ what are the implications?


Terminology and framing of events: why is it crucial to think/critique the ways in information (through language/narratives/images etc) that we receive about violence: “the frame works both to preclude certain kinds of questions [and] historical inquiries, and to function as a moral justification for retaliation” (4). Find examples of the dangers and the alternatives that Butler suggests.


Find other places in the text to unpack what Butler mean when she asks, “Can we find another meaning, and another possibility, for the decentering of the first-person narrative within the global framework?” (7).



Butler asks, “What social conditions help to form the very ways that choice and deliberation proceed? . . .” (16) Explore her discussion around these questions.


“Who counts as human?” (20). Why are the experiences of loss, vulnerability, grief, mourning integral to Butler’s thesis? Do we agree that these are universal human experiences that might be a source of moral response?


“Let’s face it, we’re undone by each other. And if we’re not, we’re missing something_ (23) Do you have a significant moment from service that illustrates this?

Significance of the discussion of identity/autonomy/the body (24-38). Tie back to other points. This leads into important discussion of vulnerability—how does she then tie this back into the previous points she has built?


Dehumanization of the Other 32-49. Crucial points here and she weaves in all the other points.


“We do not need to ground ourselves in a single model of communication, a single model of reason, a single notion of the subject before we are able to act” (48). Think about this in relation to the thesis Butler has built and, if possible, in relation to your service-learning experience.
Do you see echoes of Arendt in any of Butler’s points? Where? There are also many points about vulnerability that remind me of the reading from On Kindness. Also, think back to Deo and the violence and loss he experienced, does his story illustrate some of Butler's ideas as well? What about the Cornell piece on the "Moral Obligations of Living in a Democratic Society" and the necessary struggles and asking of hard questions. . .?(Finding common themes, that are also illuminated through your service experience, will help you formulate your final paper.)

Here are some things that I usually show and listen to in class in conjunction with this reading.

Butler asks: "If 200,000 Iraqi children were killed during the Gulf War and its aftermath, do we have an image, a frame for any of those lives, singly or collectively? Is there a story we might find about those deaths in the media? Are there names attached to those children?" (34).
Her questions point to the ways in which it is easier to live with war and violence when we dehumanize the Other instead of realizing our shared humanity. We are able to distance ourselves, and as we know from reading "The Moral Mind," it is easier to not feel empathy when we are dealing with numbers and not human stories. s.

Please watch the clip from The War Photographer that I have embedded below-I own the DVD and often show much of it in class, you can probably find more clips on You-Tube. James Natchwey strives to show us the difficult realities--if we can't see them how can we change them?
Natchwey has the ideals of the whistleblower--he must tell and show the truth and he does sacrifice a lot to do so. This is particularly poignant after the recent deaths of the photographers in Libya. Yes, war photographers die trying to give us the real images and stories. He also has a powerful TED talk.


Additionally, I often play this episode of This American Life:

Act 1 is about the collateral damage of war and the issues of actually trying to honor the dead by getting an accurate count. Act 2 is the one that I usually play (mostly because it is shorter and it is also about human beings in the Army trying to do the right thing which involves being close-up, feeling the grief and loss, and accepting collective and personal responsibility for the suffering of others and in this way keeping their own humanity, even in war, and even at the cost of the burden of this knowledge:

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.