Thursday, April 14, 2011
Do you moralize your narcissism? Wait, I couldn't hear you I was looking at my reflection in the pond!
This blog will cover pp. 63-96. As previously stated in my first blog about Whistleblowers I see how people can value their opinion enough to see how everybody should think like them. They hold their ideals so sacred that they tend to live their lives based on such values. I am truly enthralled by internal dialogue (aka self-talk). I often instruct my clients that if they were to be better acquainted with their internal dialogue, they would alleviate some/ most of their problems. It seems as though Alford is saying some of the same things here in his book. "The narrative structure is always the same, a conversation of voices within the whistleblower" (p.65). I digress as I tell you that one of my favorite bumperstickers is "A thousand voices singing to an audeince of one!". Hannah Arendt's writes about "training your imagination to go visiting" (p.67). It is clear to see in Alford's book how almost a true disconnect happens. Here is where the two types of narcissism are similar, a lack of others. "If whistleblowers are connected in an almost visceral way with the consequences of their acts" (p.67). Yet, he states they are not connected in the same way with those who are affected by their whistleblowing. I find it interesting the way Alford puts the "identification with the victim is more about resistance than compassion" (p.85). It is like the whistleblower is saying to him/ herself, "The autonomy of the ideal self takes precedence/ is greater than even that individual who was affected by the act/ event". And finally no blog would be complete with a psychology major commenting on Arendt's labeling of Socrates dismay about "being asked to corrupt himself to be a citizen of Athens" (p.91). I truly believe that speaking in Freudian/ psychoanalytical terms, what plagues the whistleblower the most is not Sigmund's cocaine or cigars, but his depiction of the superego. Note to Audience: The corporation or governmental agency will play the part of the "id" in the mind, subsequent self-talk, and the moralization of the whistleblower's narcissism.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.