Saturday, April 16, 2011

Should I...Shouldn't I



Chapter One. p.6-7 (goal and methodology of the book).

“To be a whistleblower is to step outside the Great Chain of Being, to join not just another religion, but another world” (6). Alford's goal in writing Whistleblowers is to raise a question. “What does the organization look like from the perspective of someone who has been forcibly relocated to this other world” (6). He compares the choice to blow the whistle to “space-walking,” in which the individual steps beyond or outside the parameters of society. Alford's methodology is to listen to the stories of the whistleblower, and then examine the sources of “disorder” and “conflict of voices” in the whistleblower's life in order to form his theories (7). He has made it clear that the book is not a 'recounting' of the whistleblower's stories, rather an attempt to use “these narratives, conveying enough of their content to share the with the reader, so as to know something about organizational life that is not apparent from the usual top-down perspective” (7).


Chapter Two. p.21, p.32 (how/why organizations 'sacrifice' whistleblowers). p.35 (workplace values).

According to Alford, the reason for how and why organizations 'sacrifice' whistleblowers is to “disrupt moral behavior” (21). By turning a blind eye the organization “quells individuality” and maintains its distance from the outside world. This is to minimize the morality of the organization's actions, because as Alford says, “Talking about what we are doing means talking about how what we do affects others” (22). Organizations use demoralization and humiliation to put “...him or her under so much psychological stress that it becomes difficult to do a good job” (32). Other tactics used by organizations to get the desired outcome (employee termination) are to transfer them into positions which they are not trained for, relocation to less comfortable working environments, and to “...transform an act of whistleblowing from an issue of policy and principle into an act of private disobedience and psychological disturbance” (32). It is interesting and disturbing to think of an organization taking steps to make the whistleblower the issue, but in the end, the organization doesn't want morality to interfere with productivity or profit. Alford makes an interesting observation about workplace values and their possible influence on democratic values when he refers to Richard Sennett's beliefs “...that the values of the contemporary workplace are undermining the values of the rest of our lives. The fate of the whistleblower heightens these issues, showing that not only does the modern organization do little to foster civic values but that it is committed to the destruction of the individual who displays them” (35).


Chapter Three. p.61-62. (failure of common narrative and how the organization disciplines the ethical individual).

Organizations look for justifiable reasons to terminate the ethical individual (whistleblower). These reasons can alienate the whistleblower from the society he or she has been fighting to protect and live with in. When the organization turns the table on the whistleblower and takes away their power, (their narrative) the whistleblower becomes obsolete. Without an audience to hear the story, the story does not exist. One whistleblower responded to when this occurs, “I have seen the truth, and the truth has shaken my belief in who I am because it has shaken my belief in the world I live in” (61). Organizations have sent individuals to see doctors as a way to place them on medical leave, and say they are too sick to work. This in effect removes the problem from the organization because he or she is not allowed to be in it. Organizations can also force an individual into early retirement with seductive benefit packages removing the threat with severance pay.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.