Saturday, April 16, 2011

Not Such a Bad Thing


Chapter Four, p.76 (narcissism moralized).

“Narcissism moralized” – at first I thought this was negative. I have images in my head of a friend from high school who used to look at himself in the reflection of the school windows. This was my definition and understanding of what it meant to be narcissistic: in love with yourself, and only yourself. Alford challenges this when he speaks of how the whistleblower feels “...contaminated by the corruption of others” (76), because the view of themselves as being “...good, whole, and pure has been corrupted, and they feel ashamed” (76). Alford believes that this loss of wholeness and purity is the “...most important illusion of all. The illusion is narcissism” (76). He continues by saying the narcissist may be viewed as something other than negative if he or she “...raises himself to become one with high ideals, what I call narcissism moralized, or whether the narcissist lowers his ideals to meet the frustrated self” (76). This reminds me of our class discussion and the excerpt from Dan Pink's The Good Life, where we discussed the differences between 'profit goals,' and 'purpose goals.' The belief that “...attainment of a particular set of goals [in this case, profit goals] has no impact on well-being and actually contributes to ill-being” (Pink, 144). Take my high school friend who loved to make sure he looked good at every school window for example, his narcissism was not contributing to his happiness, it was in fact making him more self-conscious and the more he looked the more things he found that he thought he needed to change. Narcissism moralized relates to the whistleblower's sense of identity – everything reflects on them the right and true which they believe is shared by all. From the development of the ego, the infant believes he or she is the entire universe. Everything is me. Through ego separation you form the ideal principle – interconnectedness with the world, the self merging with the larger world. If we look at the whistleblower in this fashion, than the illusions they have are the positive hopes and beliefs in a good, whole, and pure world, which are actually positives. As Alford explains, “In a word, the whistleblower's narcissism has become moralized” (79).


Chapter Five, p.84-94 (Embodiment).

“Impartialist moral theory, the most popular theory in the Western world, is concerned with principles, obligations, and duties that are equally binding on all men and women in similar situations” (84). This, as Alford explains, is why the whistleblower feels shame - “Whistleblowers blow the whistle because they dread living with a corrupted self more than they dread isolation from others” (90). Another phrase I found interesting is when Alford explains that even though the whistleblower is concerned with the suffering of others, this is not why he or she acts. “The whistleblower acts because the unjust suffering of others leads the whistleblower to feel morally corrupted by association” (89). Another interesting phrase is Alford's position on Arendt's views of thought. He believes thinking leads to self-deception. “Not thinking but the self-revulsion that stems from having failed to live up to high ideals, the self-revulsion that so often takes the form of feeling corrupted by others' misdeeds, is the motive force. Thinking only (and it is a big 'only') makes this feeling more available” (92). Also one last phrase that caught my attention was Alford's suggestion that morality is more narcissistic than we think. “...morality is neither impartial nor particularistic. Morality is narcissistic, concerned to preserve the moral purity of the self. From this perspective, the question becomes not whether but how the self involves others in the project of its moral perfection” (94).

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.