Butler explained how communication from the government and media discouraged open discussion about the war and how the popular opinion was guided to support the war effort. She commented, “to oppose the war meant to some that one somehow felt sympathy with terrorism, or that some saw the terror as justified” (2). The idea of possibly giving support to such horrible actions by stating an opinion, effectively silenced people.
Butler suggest that we should at least be open to conversation and not put people down because they want to review the topic of terror, retaliation, and war objectively. She asks to separate the discussion from the act of war; “allow an intellectual field to redevelop more responsible distinctions...and accountability might be understood apart from claims of vengeance” (3). Examination could provide alternate paths to approaching with the issue. Personally, I appreciate her comments because I did not agree with quickly going to war. We have expected other countries have to deal with painful circumstances and we have been influenced by mindfulness type of ideas from the east, yet we seemed to react rather than explore alternatives.
Butler portrayed the rise of anti-intellectualism by explaining the lack of support for questioning the government. She stated,“critical relation to government has been severely, though not fully, suspended”(1). Individuals are further discouraged from thoughtful inquiry due to the suggestion that it is unpatriotic to do so. Comments such as, “the time to reassert not only American values but fundamental and absolute values has arrived” (2) and “using the flag as a sign of solidarity with those lost on September 11 and with the current war(3). Implying if you are a true, loyal American, you will not question our involvement in the war.
Butler describes the effects of how events are framed, “the frame works both to preclude certain kinda of questions, certain kinds of historical inquires, and to function as a moral justification for retaliation”(4) and
“the frame decides, in a forceful way, what we can hear” (5). The manner in which the situation is presented suggests how it should be interpreted and the appropriate reaction, thereby controlling the general public’s response.
Butler examines our personal grief process and notes that we don’t realize the growth and potentially positive side of the loss until we have made it through much of the pain. She asks if our country could benefit from similar reflection and asks, “are we not interested in ameliorating this violence? are we not obligated to stop it’s further dissemination, to consider our role in instigating it, and to foment and cultivate another sense of culturally diverse global political culture” (9). Through this process we might find another meaning and take different action that will benefit countries throughout the world.
Butler discusses the universal human connection of loss and that we are all subject to violence because we have a body. She explains
how human loss (death) can be recognized or ignored and connects how this serves political purposes. Minimizing and ignoring deaths means the difficult questions of why and how do not have to be answered.
I absolutely agree with you. After 9/11 Americans lost something very powerful, their freedom to think and free speech. If anyone would say anything "negative" about the government it was taken as "anti patriotic." We were all forced to think like the government and not question it.
ReplyDeleteBut we must also be aware that many innocent Muslim Americans lost their freedom in many ways, especially their freedom to practice their religion. They were targeted because of their ethnicity, doesn't this sound familiar? It seems like history continues to repeat itself and we never seem to learn the real lesson. Butler is right, it is time to take different approach and instead of doing all the action and talking we need to sit back and listen to what other have to say, either that or horrific events will continue to repeat.