Thursday, April 21, 2011

Permeable Boundaries! Are you In or Out?

Once again we are faced with the ethical dilemma (sorry for implying there are only two choices with the use of "dilemma") of the whistleblower. On p. 98, Al Ripskis, a whistleblower, says "it is a hell of a commentary on our contemporary society when you must be ready to become an insolvent pariah if you want to live up to your own ethical standards". Personally I would rather live with my own transgressions in Maui then be solvent because I felt obligated by my moralized narcissism. I much prefer the clinical version of this pathology. I guess both would be considered what my stepfather used to call, IGM syndrome- "I Got Mine!".
I believe that Alford is saying that the organization's drives and structure come from a collective transgression (p.98) that it needs all of its "units" to abide by (p.99). I believe that the organization is a feudal system because it holds all the power and abilities for transgressions. It is a collective transgression that makes the organization work, however, the organization must be careful and at times a little paranoid because the outside units are operating with this organization.
I really liked the Greek word "pharmakos" (p.125) because it describes the dichotomy of the whistleblower. Because in the whistleblower's eyes, everybody should stand by to the death for their ethical standards, a type of cure. While their own actions are the poison. Hence the duality of definition of parmakos. One's perspective is that ethics are the only true way to live, when in reality for the whistleblower it means death to so many things in their life (ie financial, employability, familial, etc.). "The pharmakos is the cure in the sense that the original scapegoat is cure".Alford points out that rarely does the scapegoat's action have a bunch of people standing up to be counted. Rather, it is in their actions that we see how we must keep the information at a distance, because we could not actually accept the new knowledge.
Interesting concept of Girard saying that "What sacrifice looks like now is law" (p.128) when he contends that scapegoating is a collective means of violence and it is against the victim (or perpetrator/ whistleblower) that will have no reprise.
I believe that Mary Manson (p.120) says what is the essential statement when evaluating the experience of the whistleblower."I have never felt so forsaken in all my life as when I blew the whistle...no, that's not what I mean. I felt worse in the couple years leading up to blowing this whistle." I find it ironic that she changed her thought/ words in describing her experience. I wonder what her life would be like had she reframed her moralized narcissism as she had done with her thoughts and words here...

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.