On page 33, an interesting discussion continues that I feel is at the crux of every population that is minimalized and persecuted. If a perpetrator sees the victim as an object (seen in racism sexism, and sexual orientation hate crimes), then it is easier to be an offender with no subsequent guilt. What author Butler calls the Other or the derealization. I see how the media plays the most important role in doing this with Muslims today. Bible thumpers see the LGBT culture like this. It is very hard in my life to hate anyone when I sit next to them and converse. It is very easy to hate someone with little or no information about them and previous information has portrayed them as someone I should hate or see as "The Other-neither alive nor dead" (p.33).
Thursday, April 28, 2011
Contempt Prior To Investigation!
The title of this blog is the answer "Contempt Prior To Investigation". The question is 'What will keep a man in everlasting ignorance"- Herbert Spencer. Either on an individual or group basis, the means must justify end.One of my favorite quotes in this reading came on early. it is: But it is one matter to suffer violence and quite another to use that fact to ground a framework in which one's injury authorizes limitless aggression against targets that may or may not be related to the sources of one's own suffering" (p.4). I feel that whether it be September 11th, the Three Strikes Law, or some other emotionally-charged decision, the follow-up violence has done much more harm than the original act. My Irish cousins, 7 years old, get bombs thrown at them in Belfast. Our ethnocentrism is alarming. I am American through and through, but I refuse to become a non-thinking member of this nation. We did have a part in September 11th. The 2,800 people killed in that tragedy did not. Our foreign policy did. Yet the policymakers refuse to look at the etiology of those events. Whether at home or abroad, our government's actions are never called into question. "Our own acts of violence do not receive graphic coverage in the press" (p.6). I have to mention both home and abroad even though the text is talking about our foreign wars. I feel that it is important to mention this because American citizens (Muslim Americans) are being held responsible for fanatical extremists. I know sure as sh.. I do not want to be lumped in a general Christian American group with Falwell and the Nuts! I can not help but think of the last reading where I learned the word "pharmakos". This term means both cure and poison. In fact it is the misalignment of America's framework in the global setting that has us believing that we have "the cure" when in actuality, our actions have prompted "the poison". One of the text points set for by Judith ask about social conditions and how they help form the very ways that choice and deliberation proceed. With regard to our actions after 9/11, "In pursuing a wayward military solution, the United States perpetrates and displays its own violence offering s breeding ground for new waves of young muslims to join terrorist organizations" (p.17).
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
“I am American through and through, but I refuse to become a non-thinking member of this nation. We did have a part in September 11th. The 2,800 people killed in that tragedy did not. Our foreign policy did. Yet the policymakers refuse to look at the etiology of those events. Whether at home or abroad, our government's actions are never called into question” (Kenny).
ReplyDeleteKenny you make a poignant observation. I agree with you completely. It's sad that our nation (which has been through so much), is represented by a government that has its own agenda – contrary to what the public wants – and that the people are the ones who elect those that represent our country. I've always hated the stigma that comes with traveling abroad as an American. I have had friends tell me they put Canada patches on their luggage to try and slip under the radar, or whenever asked “Where are you from?” the safest response is some where other than America.
“I can not help but think of the last reading where I learned the word "pharmakos". This term means both cure and poison. In fact it is the misalignment of America's framework in the global setting that has us believing that we have "the cure" when in actuality, our actions have prompted 'the poison' ” (Kenny).
The United States has put itself into the position of 'big brother' or 'global protector' under the guise of ridding the world of terrorists. Our government jumped into the conflict in Libya to 'help out' NATO – it seems they all (coalition forces) believed the US would have a more prominent role, but once things got under way our government basically handed operations off to others. Creating a mess that someone else is going to have to deal with – a new American Way? No wonder why our global perception is so bad.
“On page 33, an interesting discussion continues that I feel is at the crux of every population that is minimalized and persecuted. If a perpetrator sees the victim as an object (seen in racism sexism, and sexual orientation hate crimes), then it is easier to be an offender with no subsequent guilt” (Kenny).
This makes me think about our military and the increasing use of Drones to carry out strikes. The separation in distance from the target seems to perpetuate the separation of guilt. If we can't hear, smell or touch the target than the chances of Drones carrying out strikes increases – no American casualties, and an emotional and psychological distance creates the perfect recipe for future warfare.