Thursday, April 28, 2011

My evening riff that started as a response to Kenny!

So--this is really for everyone because I go into a long piece here that threads it's way very informally through some of our past readings. . .
Kenny you go right to the heart of Butler's points and do so with power. The first part of your post really echoes the central points in "The Brain is an Argument"--that much of what we call rational thought is actually a rationalization of our emotionally driven choices and beliefs. Butler is saying that although 911 was clearly a tragedy, it was also an opportunity to be reflective rather than reactive. It was an opportunity to look at ourselves, as individuals and as a nation. We give ourselves over to that policy level authority when we fail to question, to say no, to protest the usurping of our basic rights--yes, our "freedoms." For those of you familiar w/Naomi Klein's work--this is the shock doctrine in action. Many policy level changes happen when people are too decentered to question. And then, as we saw post-911 and Butler notes in the first pages, we saw the rise of anti-anti-intellectualism. Anyone who dared raise "why" questions was deemed "unpatriotic."
Then of course, the policy level decisions are carried out by the people on the ground who must cope with the realities of war, and like Deo, live with the horror. The media rarely tells the stories, or not enough, of those who are like the whistleblowers live in dread or like the dead, who carry the knowledge of suffering, of violence, of loss, and grief.
Because we know from "The Moral Mind," that we are desensitized by numbers and data, we rarely are exposed to the stories, the faces of suffering.
Butler suggests, like the authors of On Kindness, that we are transformed, "undone" by both the pains and the joys of our connections with others. Deo experienced persecution and he had to walk away from a child, yet despite his PTSD he used this knowledge to expand his humanity. I believe this happens for many who allow themselves or are forced to experience our whole reality. We are just as afraid of love, generosity, kindness as we are of our own potential to persecute and be persecuted--because both experiences are beyond our control and render us vulnerable. But, we ARE vulnerable. Butler's point is that it is part of what it means to be human, and if we refuse to engage with others, we lose our own capacity for greater humanity. So, at the heart of the ethical challenge is the challenge to open ourselves to our interdependent reality (all the whistleblower ideals) that we share with ALL human beings. We have a potential to be hurt, to lose those whom we love, to grieve and at the same time to share our pain and to come out the other side, transformed, as Deo did. But we also have to chose to have that inner Socratic dialogue, to draw on the emotions that help us to imagine and to cross that bridge of otherness at the same time that we do a self-check to understand the difference between knee-jerk emotional reactions and real THINKING.
OK, there's my stream of consciousness for the evening--!

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.