“Our fear of understanding a point of view belies a deeper fear that we shall be taken up by it, find it is contagious, become infected in a morally perilous way by the thinking of the presumed enemy” (8). Wow. Funny thing, while reading this I was not thinking about the U.S. 'rooting out' terrorists, or the government's view of our place within the global framework. After reading this section I was immediately drawn to my Service Learning partner Spectrum, and the issues they face from those who are uneducated. I became aware of this sense of fear that Butler is talking about while doing research for Spectrum. The fear comes from those people, parents, teachers, or administrators who are too ignorant about the subject of LGBT that they would 'black ball' or discourage Spectrum from coming to their school and talking to their students, teachers, and staff because of the reasons Butler mentions above. I have found a genuine fear that parents, teachers and administration, believe that if they allow Spectrum to talk about LGBT issues, than the students will become lesbian, gay or bisexual overnight just by hearing about alternative lifestyles.
Butler's reasoning speaks to the heart of this ignorant logic. “But instead of remaining open to a consequential decentering of First Worldism, we tend to dismiss any effort at explanation, as if to explain these events would involve us in a sympathetic identification with the oppressor, as if to understand these events would involve building a justificatory framework for them” (8). This is precisely why homophobia still exists and the illogical barrier that LGBT and Spectrum have to find a way to penetrate.
Jason, It is a nice break to NOT hear about the "terrorist" propaganda, isn't it? I remember the Cold War where somehow the Big Red Communist machine was going to come right under the Golden Gate Bridge and "infect" us with theri way of life. I feel that our service learning arenas are very similar even though one has to do with ethnicity and the other sexual orientation. I feel the large insidious common denominator is ignorance. The ignorance of people toward the LGBT community is very similar to that of people that are not in the status quo. I am working with the Latino male population and I see clearly where this population has been marginalized much like that of Spectrum.
ReplyDeleteI second Kenny--this is exactly the way that we "other" any one different who doesn't fit our "norm"--right on "target" Jason. (I find myself very aware of the fact that the language of killing is so embedded in our mode of expression--I realize that I wrote that Kenny went "right to the heart" and I didn't mean it in this sense but of course this and "on target" are the same thing.) RIGHT ON, Jason. Just right on point or power to the point or. . . We need new vocabulary and metaphors to help our paradigm shift don't we?
ReplyDeleteIn response to Jason’s post: Butler said, “Our fear of understanding a point of view belies a deeper fear that we shall be taken up by it, find it contagious, become infected in a morally perilous way by the thinking of the presumed enemy”. Jason’s research about Spectrum taught him that the fear felt by parents, teachers, or administrators is so strong that they would black ball or discourage Spectrum from coming to their school to educate their students, teachers and administration about alternative lifestyles. Speaking as a parent, I would welcome any information that might help or save even one child from the ostracism and loneliness they must feel, having to confront their “alternate lifestyle” without the support or understanding of their parents, teachers, and school. The “others” as Schneider refers to them in Rediscovery of Awe, whose support could provide a “fathomless well of sustenance throughout adult life”, have a duty to listen and learn from Spectrums information when given the opportunity. When we hear or read about a young person committing suicide because they had no support and no one to turn to, we have to wonder if the very people in position to become informed and help chose not to because of the “genuine fear” Jason spoke of.
ReplyDelete